The latest convictions in the George Floyd case: a watershed moment for the US
By Catie Albanesi
George Floyd’s death at the hands of Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, who knelt on Floyd’s neck for over nine minutes, reignited the Black Lives Matter movement. This extreme act of violence, amounting to second-degree murder, was one example of the outcome of a police system plagued by racism and deficient accountability.
Over a year after Floyd’s death, in June of 2021 Chauvin received a sentence of 22.5 years following his conviction for second-degree murder. This marked a notable change from the US justice system’s lack of persecution for similar crimes committed by law enforcement officers, especially for crimes committed against black Americans.
The decision is a watershed moment for the US
Last week, the three other officers who were at the killing of Floyd, Tou Thao, J. Alexander Kueng, and Thomas Lane, faced a trial for their complicity. Kueng and Lane both restrained Floyd with Chauvin, while Thao kept bystanders away. The jury found all three officers guilty of failing to intervene and for failing to provide medical attention to Floyd, violating his constitutional rights.
This decision is a watershed moment for the US, setting a precedent that prosecution for unjust police brutality will extend beyond the officers committing the acts, but those who abet or watch it occur. According to Christy E. Lopez, a law professor from Georgetown Law School, the decision “shifts the entire narrative from misconduct being about just acts of commission to misconduct also being about acts of omission.”
Following the same idea, one of the key tenets of the reinvigorated BLM movement is the idea that all police officers are involved in the perpetuation of the institutional racism that results in the unreasonable use of violence, often simplified by the acronym ‘ACAB’ (‘All Cops Are Bastards’). This case was one of the first instances where substantial legal action has been taken to combat the institutional issues of complicity within the law enforcement system.
Fostering responsibility among officers for their actions in instances such as Floyd’s will be difficult work. California Western International Law Journal finds that the police culture in the US is marked by a lack of internal accountability. There is a ‘code of silence’ among officers that compromises the integrity of investigations undertaken by the department’s internal affairs units. In fact, 72% of US officers disagree with the statement: “[O]fficers who consistently do a poor job are held accountable.” (PEW Social Trends).
The lack of accountability has directly led to the deaths of innocent people. For example, Michael Craig was shot in his home by a Chicago police officer after calling the police because his wife was threatening him with a knife in October of last year. After shooting Craig, the unnamed officer left him to bleed out from both the gunshot wound and where he was stabbed by his wife. (More can be read about Craig’s story here.)
Prior to this instance, the officer had faced termination in 2016 for assault charges, in addition to disorderly conduct charges in 1999 and an arrest in 2010 that resulted in 4 months of probation. Despite his history, he was unanimously reinstated by the police board in 2019. The lawyer representing the Craig family believes that Craig would still be alive if the officer had been liable for his previous actions.
Courts can play a role in holding officers accountable
Additionally, Thao, Kueng, and Lane’s lawyers cite the hierarchical culture present in the Minneapolis police department as contributing to the officers’ actions; as Chauvin was their superior, they were expected culturally to conform to his actions. The court decided that an officer’s duty to uphold the civil rights of civilians is more important than maintaining the pecking order – a decision that has the potential to change the cultural structure of police forces.
These long-standing cultures can be difficult to replace, especially with resistance to the changes from within the organization, however, courts can play a role in holding officers accountable externally. If officers know their action (or inaction) will be prosecuted, perhaps they will be more likely to intervene and prevent police brutality from occurring. Additionally, this could encourage action from police departments to foster systemic changes to accountability systems.
However, the progress made in last week’s ruling depends on whether other cases – especially those with less publicity than Floyd’s – will be met with similar decisions to hold officers responsible. Hopefully, this case will set a precedent in the ruling of future police brutality cases, and lead to further institutional changes for US police forces.
Image: munshots via Unsplash.

