The danger of losing local journalism
By Catie Albanesi
Since 2004, over 1,800 newspapers in the United States have been closed, with an average of 100 papers closing each year (PEW Research). In the United Kingdom, 265 papers shut between 2005 and 2020 (Press Gazette). Most of the closures, in both the US and UK, were regional, weekly newspapers.
A rise in digitised editorial content, social media tabloids, and television broadcasting have all replaced consumer demand for physical newspapers — where companies make the majority of their profits. Combine this with economic hardship associated with the pandemic and increasingly disinterested advertisers, the journalism industry has become extremely hostile, ultimately resulting in papers closing, reducing production, or merging into larger conglomerates.
The most notable conglomerate is News Corp, owned by mogul Rupert Murdoch. His media empire includes Fox News, The Wall Street Journal, The Sun, and The Times among many other notable publications. Through the process of buying out dying newspapers and incorporating them into his journalistic ecosystem, he has amassed a notorious right-wing monopoly on the industry. The effect of which has had a wide-spread impact on the lives of people across the world.
Regional papers are less likely to intentionally publish misleading information
In the US, Fox News‘ 24-hour news cycle has become notorious for spreading misinformation about the Covid-19 vaccine, turning science into a political debate. Additionally, the company’s fear-mongering continues to publicise a false narrative of persecution among the unvaccinated which has resulted in violent protests across the country, including protesters threatening to burn down schools in New York.
The backbone of democracy is the dissemination of truth. Conversely, the dissemination of misinformation has led to the rise of authoritarianism throughout the free world. Campaigns run on lies spread by News Corp have fundamentally changed the face of politics. On the whole, regional papers are less likely to intentionally publish misleading information. Unlike national papers, local news companies maintain higher standards of fact-checking and subbing, ultimately leading to more trustworthy sources according to the Edelman Trust Barometer.
Additionally, journalists working at the local level do a majority of the fieldwork that is later parroted by larger papers. A study out of Duke University found that local newspapers produce 47% of original news stories while only representing 25% of media outlets. These journals play an essential role in providing accurate, relevant information about their communities, including local elections and other ‘small town’ issues that are often just as if not more relevant to the lives of everyday people than national issues.
Regional journalism needs to survive this current trough
Throughout the pandemic, local newspapers did a majority of the essential reporting about outbreaks, infection rates, hospitalizations, and vaccination opportunities. This information became essential in informing policy. Voters and politicians alike continue to use this information to assess the effectiveness of infection-reducing measures such as mask mandates and lockdowns.
Regional journalism needs to survive the current trough in order to continue to inform the public, and it is our responsibility to save it. According to Joyce Dehli, co-chair of the Pulitzer board, “our starting point must be an affirmation of the importance of deeply reported, professional local journalism as an essential force in our democracy.”
A step further that many local papers have begun to take is to digitise their content. From there, they can reduce costs by being less reliant on physical papers, which will significantly reduce distribution costs while reaching a wider audience since online articles are more accessible than printed ones.
As for consumers, the most important step that can be taken is to diversify your media consumption. By supporting local papers through either a newspaper subscription or reading articles online, you can stay informed on issues of local importance while keeping an essential democratic institution afloat.
Image: AbsolutVision via Unsplash

