The ethics of dark academia

By Ella Maurici

Dark academia novels, first brought into the mainstream literary sphere by Donna Tartt’s The Secret History, have recently found new life through their popularity in the world of ‘Booktok’, providing idyllic but also highly satirised depictions of the university experience. Images of walking in the night upon cobblestone streets, studying the classics and living in ancient buildings may seem familiar to some Durham students, but there are also drawbacks of presenting higher education in this idealised way, focussing on ‘aesthetics’ rather than the real world.

Tartt’s The Secret History, arguably the most well-known dark academia novel, effectively displays the issues with placing intelligent, rich young people in a small, heated academic setting, inspired by Tartt’s own time spent at Bennington College in Vermont. However, despite her obvious satire of her characters throughout, she also forges a culture of a dark escapism, in which the reader readily forgives these beautiful, intelligent, yet ultimately immoral and evil characters because of their ‘aesthetics’.

The reader readily forgives these beautiful, intelligent, yet ultimately immoral and evil characters because of their ‘aesthetics’

Tartt uses her characters’ unrealistic actions to ironise their perception of their own intellectual superiority. Her wealthy, intelligent characters that are so typical of dark academia books are presented as not being concerned with any consequences of their actions, a dangerous notion often seen in real life academic institutions. This is particularly prevalent in their perception of the incorrect notion that someone’s social class is directly proportional to their intelligence, an ideal which Tartt ultimately criticises. However, these characters are still presented as much more compelling than those sitting outside of their exclusive social circles, such as the character Judy Poovey, whose very name exudes triviality, and is forbidden from entering the dark academia circles within the novel.

The narrator in such novels is typically drawn into dangerous cliques or societies, pulling them, unaware, into the world of dark academia. This is no normal university society induction or building of a friendship, but rather an inescapable draw into a dangerous yet alluring world. This idea’s literary origins can be seen in the 20th century campus novel, particularly Waugh’s Brideshead Revisited in which the narrator, Charles, is so drawn to his university friend Sebastian that their relationship transcends the bounds of their academic life, resulting in Charles’ fascination with Sebastian’s aristocratic family and their home. This is similar, but executed differently, in Mona Awad’s Bunny, an experimental novel which furthers the satire of elite educational institutions in the dark academia sub-genre. Once the narrator, Samantha, is taken in by a group of girls calling themselves ‘Bunnies’, the actual structure of the novel, both on a sentence and greater narrative level, is thrown into confusion. This is different from The Secret History, in which the narrator, Richard, controls his narrative, telling his story in the past, in a way much reminiscent of Charles’ narration in Brideshead Revisited. Awad instead dips into the genre of nonsense fiction to express the confusion and dangers of being taken in by dark and dangerous cliques, presenting a deeper investigation into the mechanics of the societies written about in dark academia novels along with the dangers that come with them.

Awad instead dips into … a deeper investigation into the mechanics of the societies written about in dark academia novels

However, most still agree that Tartt’s is a more successful dark academia novel. Is it a better novel? Despite Awad’s obvious awareness of Tartt’s novel, such as the title Bunny linking to a character in The Secret History, they are difficult to compare. Tartt draws you into a world in which you might forgive certain horrors because they are presented in such a beautiful, aesthetic way. Awad, on the other hand, makes the reader far more uncomfortable, separating them from the absurd events of the novel rather than dragging them in. Both novels, therefore, have merit in the sphere of dark academia and demonstrate that although such novels are often in danger of displaying a warped version of the realities of higher education, they also provide comfort to many readers by way of romanticising academia. Therefore, despite the moral drawbacks of dark academia novels, their current unwavering popularity and the comforting escapism they provide is undeniable and is not an issue as long as readers stick to the aesthetics of old buildings, autumn leaves, and studying hard, rather than focussing on the morally questionable actions of the characters.

Image: Charles Lester

https://www.dunelm.org.uk/donations/palatinate