The realities of reading romance
By Ella Maurici
Throughout the history of literature, romance novels are always considered as the epitome of popular literature and the term ‘chick-lit’ has only further evolved the rather sexist connotations of these novels and their readership. Although in recent years, there has been more acceptance of romance as a real literary trope, there is still a tendency to shove these books to the side-lines for fear of them being too idealised and not representative of the real world. Whilst Austen was writing about dinner parties and marriages, people all over England were struggling with the growth and effects of industrialisation. However, this does not mean that these dinner parties and marriages are in any way less significant than the more realistic writings about the condition of England at this time. Romance novels, both in the past and now, portray a world of escapism, in which we can focus on the beauty and individuality of human interactions, without having to be concerned with the rest of the world and in getting this glimpse of a more idealised world, we are able to ameliorate our perceptions and actions in real life.
Romance novels, both in the past and now, portray a world of escapism, in which we can focus on the beauty and individuality of human interactions, without having to be concerned with the rest of the world
Over the last few years, we have seen a rise in romance novels, stemming from the popularity of 90s classics, including Bridget Jones’ Diary, and also aided by the film adaptations of such novels. We can see that there is a certain infallible structure to romance that is incredibly comforting to the reader; the readers expect the romantic couple to be interested in each other, go through some conflict that drives them apart, and ultimately end up together and happy. Although this is not particularly realistic to life, this structure is incredibly effective in engaging readers and highlighting the great escapist power of love. Taking a very modern example, Casey McQuiston’s recent popular novels, particularly her debut of Red, White and Royal Blue, really lean into this escapism that we so often see in romance novels. In Red, White and Royal Blue, the unrealistic relationship between an English prince and the first son of the US act as the cornerstone of a beautiful world, so different from our own – a happy, sunny 2020 under Democratic leadership.
We can also see that some of the most popular recent romance novels attempt to portray the realities of modern relationships rather than always giving an idealised impression. One book that does not shy away from portraying a darker romantic relationship is Colleen Hoover’s It Ends with Us. Although the overall effects of this book are still based on the same escapist tones, Hoover writes about a relationship that starts off like that of a typical romance novel, before descending into a tale of abuse, deliberately subverting the typical structure of romance fiction, yet still ending with a different prevailing romance, which is in some ways used within the context of the novel as a form of idealistic escapism.
We can also see that some of the most popular recent romance novels attempt to portray the realities of modern relationships rather than always giving an idealised impression
Another author who portrays the realities of relationships with great success, is Sally Rooney. Rooney’s novels have gained much acclaim over recent years due to the incredible rawness in their depictions of relationships. Her novel Normal People has echoes of the typical romance between Marianne and Connell, particularly in the rekindling of their relationship throughout different times in their lives. However, Rooney’s portrayal of the harsh emotions and issues within their relationship, along with the ultimate open-endedness of Connell and Marianne’s future, allows this relationship to be much truer to real life than is typically presented in romance novels.
Therefore, romance novels can clearly be successful regardless as to whether they portray realistic relationships or not. Sometimes people can benefit more from reading about an idealised, escapist relationship and sometimes people want to read about something sadder and rawer. The fact that these differing types of romance novels have been coexisting successfully in the current literary sphere suggests that the romance genre itself is constantly evolving but that the escapist, idealistic undertones that have prevailed throughout the history of romance literature, have prevailed for a reason and that sometimes, people want to read about an idealised world and to save the more realistic, and often bleaker events, for real life.
Image Credit: Kelly Sikkema via Unsplash

