State school pupils less likely to get offers, and prefer to live in self-catered or hill colleges
By Waseem Mohamed and Frank Kelly
Palatinate has obtained data showing that, compared with the national average, independent school applicants have a greater chance of receiving an offer to Durham University than state school applicants. Data also reveals that state-educated students who enrol at Durham are more likely to select a college that is self-catered or located on the ‘hill’.
Over a five-year average, Durham made 28% fewer offers to state school applicants in comparison to the total applications made by such students, compared to 33% fewer offers made to independent school students. This is despite the fact that on average, Durham gives 4,056 more offers a year to state school students.
State school applicants vastly outnumber independent school applicants each year. On average, 4,985 more state school students applied to Durham, over the last five years. In spite of the larger number of applicants, the percentage drop-off between applications and offers for state and independent school students does not correspondingly favour state school applicants by much; just five percentage points separate offers made to state and private school students.
This new data comes as recent HESA (Higher Education Statistics Agency) findings showed that Durham has one of the lowest proportions of state educated pupils in the country. Just 61.6% of the 2020/21 cohort at Durham was state-educated.

Commenting on the figures, the 93% Club called for an internal review of the current contextual offers scheme. The club responded to Palatinate’s findings by saying “While there are some positives to draw from the data, Palatinate’s findings ultimately reaffirm that more needs to be done to ensure that Durham University more accurately reflects the wider UK student body.
“In the future, it should be expected that state schoolers receive more offers from the university, given that we account for 93% of the national student body. We call for an internal review of the current contextual offers and any access schemes in place to support those coming up from state education.”
A University spokesperson responded to the state/private split in applications and offers by saying: “At Durham University we aim to attract the brightest and best students, regardless of their background or financial circumstances. We make offers to applicants based on their merit and potential, in line with our Undergraduate Admissions Policy.
“We do not have a target for state school entrants. Instead, we are working to increase entrants from postcode quintiles with the lowest proportions of young people taking part in Higher Education.”
Palatinate has also collected data showing that state-educated students have a far stronger preference for colleges offering self-catered options in their first year. 59% of students at Durham’s four self-catered colleges are educated at state schools, whereas 20% have non-state school backgrounds. In comparison, only 49% of students at Durham’s ten fully-catered colleges were state school educated.

The data also found that state-school pupils had a slight preference for colleges located on the ‘hill’ (referring to colleges towards South Road) compared to the ‘Bailey’ colleges in the heart of the city. 54% of students at ‘hill’ colleges were state-educated, compared to 48% at ‘Bailey’ colleges.
Hatfield College was the only university college with a majority of privately educated students over the last five years – 52%. Josephine Butler had the highest proportion of state educated students, with 67% of its intake over the last five years coming from state schools.

When asked why state school students were more likely to choose self-catered colleges, the University responded by saying “Our colleges are at the heart of life at Durham and offer 17 distinct and inspiring communities which are open to all, regardless of background.
“A large part of these communities are made up of international students, postgraduate students, mature students, and students from non-traditional backgrounds who are not represented in the state school/independent school figures and demographics mentioned.”
Image: Thomas Tomlinson

