The effect of Scottish independence on British government
As the day of the vote grows ever closer, the ‘Better Together’ campaign seems to be losing its way. With the recent leak by an unknown cabinet minister serving to undermine the UK’s position that an independent Scotland would not keep the pound, the ‘No’ campaign needs to revaluate its message. Momentum in politics is everything, and right now it seems as if the campaign is overly negative and, thanks to that anonymous minister, relying on fear to carry the vote.
While it is true that this is fundamentally a Scottish issue, we in England and the other nations in the UK should still be paying attention. If Scotland were to leave, the process of decoupling could have profound consequences for politics in the rest of the UK.
As things stand, the 2015 election is difficult to call. While Labour enjoy a lead in the polls, the recent surge of support for the Tories seems to indicate their advantage is soft and could melt away come the election. Though Cameron and Osborne are seen by many as having economic competence, Miliband’s strength comes from the fact that he is seen as the most in touch. Whoever wins, it is likely that it will not be a landslide. A second coalition may form, or as is possible, one of the parties could manage a slim majority.
What we do know is that the election will take place after the independence referendum, and, if it is a ‘yes’, there will be consequences for the 2015 election which should concern us all. Scotland sends 59 MPs to Westminster, 41 of which are Labour. Given the popularity of the Liberal Democrats, it’s more than likely that at least a few of their 11 Scottish seats will be gained by Labour. A large proportion of Labour support, and MPs, come from Scotland.
If Scotland does vote to leave, and Labour win the 2015 election by a slim margin, Labour could be deprived of over 40 seats, which could easily be enough to turn a majority government in to a minority. Minority governments can easily fall, and a coalition or even a new election may be needed. Either way, the result of the 2015 election depends a great deal on the Independence vote. A Labour win similar to their victory in the 2005 election could be transformed into something resembling Conservative disappointment in 2010. On the other side, while no Conservative would want to see Scotland leave, losing only one MP would comparatively strengthen their position in the next parliament.
Essentially, it matters to all of us throughout the UK what Scotland decides to do in this vote. In the event of a ‘yes’ vote, we cannot pretend that the rest of the UK will not be affected. Though I consider the scenario I outlined to be unlikely, the fact that a period of instability in British politics could be looming should make us think about the way the UK is structured.
English devolution has never made it onto the mainstream agenda, thanks partly to the overwhelming rejection of a North East Assembly in the 2004 referendum. But, if Scotland stays, we should think about the governance of England. The Westminster parliament acts simultaneously as a quasi-federal body, above the devolved governments, and also as a national parliament for England. Given the economic and political differences between English regions, it may be time once again to ask the public how they wish to be governed, as is happening in Scotland.
Constitutional issues may not be high on the agenda, and it is understandable why they do not capture much public attention. But it is clear that while the Independence referendum is a Scottish decision, the issues that it raises will affect us all.
Photograph: Getty

