The issue with the European Commission

European_Commission_flags

By Philip Naylor

Does it matter who becomes the next President of the European Commission? Across the EU, leaders are grappling with the issue of who to appoint to what is regarded as the most important European institution. Whoever, in the end, is appointed will take the helm of the body which is tasked as the guardian of the treaties, as well as being responsible for proposing all European law – everything from roaming charges to budget monitoring.

While appointments like this always lend themselves to political bargaining, selecting a candidate for the Presidency now seems more difficult and divisive than ever. The problem lies with European Parliament elections, and translating their results in to anything resembling an expression of a European political will. They are a collection of 28 wildly different results, each of which was fought in a distinct national context.

Many have characterised May’s election as a triumph of the far-right; an angered electorate wounding the European project. France provided perhaps the most memorable result in the victory of the Front national, and Greece’s contingent of MEPs will now contain three neo-Nazis. It was not, however, a uniform event – the Dutch Party for Freedom actually lost ground, and elsewhere as in Spain, it was the far-left who saw the most gains.

Overall, though, it is clear that opposition to the EU in its current form is growing. The disparate nature of these elections is nothing new, but their fractured nature is more problematic than ever due to the attempt to graft a personal, presidential election on to the Parliament elections. 2009’s Lisbon Treaty made it clear that the results should be taken in to account when choosing the next Commission President, an eminently sensible inclusion in the treaty.

The European Parliament chose to interpret this clause as grounds for establishing a system in which each major party bloc put forward a candidate, with the eventual winner becoming President of the EU’s executive body. They duly put nominated candidates, held election debates and began Presidential-style campaigns, complete with branded campaign buses.

Polls have shown that almost all European voters were unaware of the man who ‘won’ the election.

While the attempt to link popular support to the Commission, usually seen as insulated from democratic accountability, is laudable, it was a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of the European elections. While ideally they would be fought on true European issues – like whether we enlarge the Union further and how to tackle the unemployment which is weighing down on Europe, for most they remain elections about national issues.

In the case of the UK, in which around 26% of the votes cast went to UKIP, many will have voted according to their view on European integration. But many will also have voted UKIP for other reasons – disenchantment with the system, the feeling of being left behind by Cameron’s brand of liberal conservatism or the failure of Labour to truly take on the mantle of opposition.

On the other side of the spectrum, the extreme collapse of the Liberal Democrat vote to 6% took place despite roughly half of the electorate supporting EU membership. Clegg’s toxic brand, and the ideological confusion government has brought it will have played an equal, if not greater role than their stance on Europe. Because of this, it was also too idealistic to hope that this election would be any reliable indicator of who the European electorate, as far as it exists, believed should take over from the Commission.

Many voters do not have the time or the inclination to follow elections other than the one to form their national government, and polls have shown that almost all European voters were unaware of the man who ‘won’ the election. This brings us to the current state of play in Europe. Jean-Claude Juncker, whose party bloc came first with 29% of seats, has been put forward by some as the Commission president.

His appointment, however, has seen a sharp divide between leaders. David Cameron has made clear his opposition and crucially the UK is not alone in this. As well as the domestic support of Labour, many leaders are voicing similar concerns as Cameron, including the Dutch and Swedish Prime Ministers.

While Merkel has given public support to Juncker, his appointment is far from a certainty. The leaders of Europe need to take this opportunity to show they are listening. While a different and perhaps fresher candidate would not radically change the direction of Europe, it would be an important first step in recognising there are fundamental concerns which need addressing.

Someone like Lithuania’s Dalia Grybauskaite, or Denmark’s Helle Thorning-Schmidt, would send a message that the next Commission is not business as usual, even if their appointment itself would not be a fundamental change. However, the process of reform and responding to concerns can begin – and people may be willing to listen if they sense something is changing.

Photograph by Sébastien Bertrand, Flickr.