In defence of the #nomakeupselfie

By Emily Lovelock

Initially, it was very easy to take the self-righteous moral high ground regarding the ‘#nomakeupselfie’ trend. The first trickle of pictures appeared from nowhere and was roundly scorned for their vague reference to cancer awareness, the focus instead falling on women’s ‘bravery’ in ditching the slap.

nomakeupselfie_8_million_WEB_HEADHSOT

It is unsurprising, therefore, that controversy began to emerge from the campaign very early on, with accusations flying about the slightly distasteful use of charity as a veil for vanity and the selfies’ inherent lack of proactive support for cancer sufferers.

But the ‘no make-up selfie’ quickly morphed into something far more powerful and this cynical response was put under strain. Links to instructions for self-examination were included in subsequent posts and participants began to donate to Cancer Research, urging others to do the same. It also began to sprout male counterparts, the #makeupselfie and the slightly contraversial, but equally valid, #cockinasock to raise awareness for testicular cancer.

Suddenly the campaign gained substance, with an incredible and unprecedented total of £1 million raised in just twenty four hours and the current total standing at over £8 million.

The importance of this donation cannot be underplayed; all it takes is a quick scroll through the Facebook page of Cancer Research UK to fully appreciate the magnitude of this entirely unexpected windfall. A particularly poignant post states that “children with acute myeloid leukaemia (AML)…will have their next clinical trial funded through the #nomakeupselfie and other selfie pictures and donations,” accompanied with an image of a ‘Thank you’ sign created by the children themselves. Debating whether the means used to raise this money was laced with vanity and narcissism suddenly felt petty and meaningless.

Ultimately, that which has been fundraised will be utilised meticulously to help people who need it desperately. And that is what really matters.

Ultimately, that which has been fundraised will be utilised meticulously to help people who need it desperately. And that is what really matters.

Yet somehow the response to the #nomakeupselfie remains overwhelmingly negative. It has come under fire for trivialising an important issue, for having little obvious link with the cause which it supports and for promoting unsustainable lump donations rather than regular giving.

The trouble is that no fundraising event is perfect and the same could be said for almost any charity event.

The fact that someone wears a chicken suit to run the London Marathon to support WaterAid does not detract from their achievement, and does not diminish their fundraising total. Wearing a Red Nose for Comic Relief does not trivialise the organisation’s work in the fight against HIV and malaria.

The trouble is that no fundraising event is perfect and the same could be said for almost any charity event.

Furthermore, as great as it would be for everyone who donated due to the #nomakeupselfie to start giving regularly to charity this is not necessarily realistic. With so many worthwhile causes asking for monthly donation it follows that for every direct debit that is set up there will always be other, equally important, causes being short changed. Few people can afford to give regularly to every charity that they would like to. It is for this reason that much charitable giving depends on specific events to raise awareness and funds, from the televised Children in Need, to fun runs to bake sales. The #nomakeupselfie is merely an extension of this tradition.

Overall, the simple fact is that the vast majority of people who donated or raised awareness for Cancer Research as a result of the #nomakeupselfie trend would never have thought to do so if it had not been for this surprise campaign. This begs the question of why exactly the phenomenon remains so controversial.

In itself, the positive use of social media is a breath of fresh air in the virtual world of trolling, cyberbullying and the recent #neknominate trend. The #nomakeupselfie campaign had its flaws; it did not, for example, raise awareness equally for all forms of cancer and it does display how one off donations to make people feel good about themselves take prevalence over sustained giving. Yet at its heart, the #nomakeupselfie was well meaning.

It shows a vast number of individuals who, essentially, just wanted to help other people. A small, imperfect action multiplied thousands and thousands of times over raised £8 million. £8 million that will make an astronomical difference to those who need it, rather than being dispersed into the millions of packets of chewing gum, drinks and inconsequential trinkets on which it might otherwise have been spent.

Photograph: Cancer Research UK