There’s plenty of time for Shakespeare

By Emily Lovelock

Even as an English student it is difficult to deny the fact that Shakespeare’s work elicits a wide spectrum of responses, ranging from fanatic enthusiasm to boredom, disgust and even despair.

shakespeare

Recent statements from Gregory Doran, artistic director of the Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC) suggesting that children as young as five should be studying original Shakespeare have therefore proved predictably controversial.

Responses appear to fit broadly into two camps: “yes, force-feed culture from an early age to prevent slackers at secondary school”. Or: “no, at the age of five it is acceptable to play in the sand and sleep in the afternoon. How could we even consider cutting childhood short?”

Many students approach Shakespeare with a preconceived trepidation and defeatist attitude when they are first confronted with the Bard at GCSE level, Doran argues, because they have heard that the work is hard.

Yet while this might be the case, the true solution might lie somewhere between these two camps. It is important to encourage young children to read, but introducing Shakespeare at such an early age could actually discourage rather than encourage a burgeoning love of literature.

Primary school children reading primary school books is a blessing, not a tragedy

It should not be forgotten that in the majority of primary schools, particularly in reception classes, there is a huge range of ability as well as exposure to literature as a whole. As a result, giving children Shakespeare at a time when they will undoubtedly find the language a struggle is demonstrably not the way to reduce preconceived fears of his plays.

Learning to read and write is a process that takes varying amounts of time dependent on the child and whilst some children will be growing up with groaning bookshelves, others will have hardly experienced literature before reaching school age. It is therefore of paramount importance that in their early school years all children are encouraged to read widely and eclectically.

Crucially, it should not be forgotten that children as young as five do not need to read Shakespeare in its original form to become enthused about it in later life.

What they need is to become thoroughly immersed in other, more accessible forms of literature to form the foundations of an interest in stories as a whole. This means the pure, unadulterated escapism of Harry Potter, which has powerful messages of tolerance and respect disguised in the elaborate and intricate world which has made it such an enduring success. Or even the more recently published, surprisingly successful Gangsta Granny (this one is a black horse, the ending is absolutely heart wrenching).

At this early age it is not impossible that the complexity of Shakespeare’s language might put some children off reading altogether.

Ultimately, there is so much time for Shakespeare in later life that it is unnecessary and even detrimental to introduce him to children at such an early age

It is all very well for those children who already have an active interest in reading, but for those who struggle with modern English, exposure to such complex material could be catastrophic for the confidence. Primary school children reading primary school books is a blessing, not a tragedy.

However, it is not as though there are no facilities for children who might develop an early interest in the immortal Bard. Shakespeare’s plays have been rewritten countless times as short stories aimed at the very young, meaning that children can approach some of the more accessible tales if they so desire. Perhaps this, then, is the way forward, allowing children to experience Shakespeare and grasp his essence without the pressure of having to decipher the unfamiliar language.

Moreover, many features of the original plays are actually highly brutal and disturbing. It is easy to think of Shakespeare’s world as one of love, masked balls and opulence, but suicide, violence and murder are also key features. Hands that cannot be washed of blood are both a literal and metaphorical presence, and even the comedies are not entirely benign. The fairies of A Midsummer Night’s Dream, for example, have a decidedly sinister edge. Adaptations specifically aimed at children are beneficial in that they can tone down some of these more intense images whilst preserving the key plots and characters, arguably the most interesting way into the canon for inexperienced readers.

Ultimately, there is so much time for Shakespeare in later life that it is unnecessary and even detrimental to introduce him to children at such an early age.

Imagine squeezing Macbeth around The Magic Key and Twelfth Night between Charlie and Lola. Quite frankly, the idea is farcical. Children’s literature is smart, funny and incredibly rich.

Let primary school children read The Magic Faraway Tree while it is still acceptable to do so and they will have a far better chance of discovering Shakespeare later in life.

Photograph: Carol Joynt