The cult of celebrity boxing: symptoms of a sport in crisis

By Ben Pawlowski

In many ways it was a glorious metaphor for a sport in crisis. 70,000 people had packed into the AT&T Stadium in Dallas, Texas, excitement and anticipation building ahead of what was widely expected to become the most viewed boxing fight in history. Jake Paul, the brash, boyish, Donald Trump-supporting former YouTuber made his entrance, about as inconspicuously as predicted as he sat atop a convertible truck, exuding levels of humility perhaps only comparable to a great Roman emperor greeting his subjects. Then his opponent, 31 years his elder, limped out, his left knee held together in a brace, his entire body understandably showing the signs of stiffness that become inevitable with ageing.

Mike Tyson, in his heyday, was unquestionably one of boxing’s greatest ever stars. A beacon of intrigue and controversy – not least after serving a three-year prison sentence for raping an 18-year-old model – “the baddest man in the world” returned to the ring at 58 years of age to face Paul in a bout that reportedly earned the former heavyweight world champion a total upwards of $20million. But this was no great return, no magnificent story of redemption or resurrection. It was a sporting, moral and societal farce.

Who could have blamed the crowd who booed as the fight (if we can call it that) came to a timid end. What they had witnessed was, genuinely, pathetic. In a bout consisting of eight two-minute rounds, using gloves larger than normal to soften the impact of punches, Tyson had landed just 18 blows, whilst his opponent, young enough to be his son, did little to provoke any excitement. The result: a unanimous victory on points for Paul.

At the same time, a far more intriguing story was underway with far less coverage. Chris Billam-Smith was facing off against his Mexican competitor Gilberto Ramirez, aiming to become the first British fighter to unite the world cruiserweight division since the great David Haye. He may have failed in his quest, but what unfolded in the ring was a thrilling advert for the sport.

Boxing, as a sport, is serving a select few. Not the spectators, not even the fighters themselves, but rather promoters, sponsors, and government officials, all of whom are seeking to benefit themselves and no one else.

Ramirez comprehensively outboxed Billam-Smith, demonstrating remarkable power and agility. But the Briton hang on, desperate to hold onto his world title belts. Despite injuries in both hands, including a fracture, his ribs and around both eyes, prompting an eight-hour stay in hospital, Billam-Smith lasted the full 12, three-minute rounds, showing Herculean levels of grit, determination and perseverance in the face of adversity. For boxing, this episode was a timely reminder of the sport’s foundational ethos.

Now contrast that with the vanity project stateside where YouTubers and other digital influencers who fancy a career change are valued over hardened fighters, ostensibly to attract younger audiences but in reality as a cash cow to be excessively milked by corporate elites. Some may see it as sensible business – after all, social media and the ‘brosphere’ is a lucrative market. But for others more cynical – me included – it appears vulgar, a grotesque infusion of influencers, shameless self-promotion, hubris and popular culture glued together with questionable integrity. In essence, capitalism and sport mixed together in its very worst, toxic form.

‘Influencer’ boxing may be the greatest symptom of the sport’s decline and diminishing prestige, but its underlying problems go far beyond the glitz and glamour seen in Dallas two weeks ago. After all, this is a sport currently in thrall to the ‘sportswashing’ programme of Saudi Arabia. The fight between Billam-Smith and Ramirez may have been absorbing, but it was held in Riyadh in front of a collection of local princes and the Newcastle United football team. It was hardly the raucous atmosphere Billam-Smith had been used to in fights back in the UK.

There are more problems, too, such as the greedy trend of writing two or three rematches into the contracts of all big fights. Some may argue that the narrative of a trilogy and the ability to watch the best fighters face off against each other more frequently can only do good to the sport, but in reality it devalues the importance of the bouts themselves. After all, how much does winning really matter if we all get together to do it all over again six months later?

It all ties into a singular narrative. Boxing, as a sport, is serving a select few. Not the spectators, not even the fighters themselves, but rather promoters, sponsors, and government officials, all of whom are seeking to benefit themselves and no one else. This is a recipe for disaster. If boxing really wants to thrive in the modern age, that needs to change.

Image: Erik Drost via Wikimedia Commons