Why has Israel banned UNRWA?

By Keelan Worwood

The current crisis in Gaza worsens following the Knesset vote on the 28th of October, passing two pieces of legislation banning UNRWA from providing service in Israel and declaring the agency a ‘terror’ group. This vote bears dire consequences for Palestinian civilians and places further strain on the wider international community’s relationship with Israel. In particular, the UK needs to assess its response following the recent US election.

The UN’s agency for Palestinian refugees, UNRWA, has provided education, healthcare and other essential services since Israel’s creation in 1948. Refugees now make up the majority of Gaza’s young population. Following Israel’s military response to the October 7th attacks, UNRWA has become more essential than ever for the preservation of civilian lives in Gaza. In the past year, 43,000 Palestinians have been killed, over 100,000 injured, and over 2.3 million displaced as Israel reduced much of the Gaza Strip to rubble.

The Knesset’s landslide result (92-10 & 87-9) in favour of effectively banning UNRWA could not have come at a worse time during such a substantial humanitarian crisis. On November 4th, the World Food Programme warned that the situation in Gaza “could soon escalate to famine”. UNRWA exists as one of the few lifelines left for millions of Palestinians. The EU’s foreign policy chief stated that the ban would render the vital operations that UNRWA runs in Gaza virtually impossible. This leaves Gaza with little to no external aid coming in, and while Israel has claimed to emphasise allocating aid for civilians separately, this has failed to materialise in any serious way. It is hard to interpret this move as anything but furthering their collective punishment despite international humanitarian law.

Israel’s animosity towards the UN does not exist in isolation but is rather entrenched in a long history of confrontation. The current right-wing coalition government has continually sowed mistrust against the UN, accusing the organisation’s general assembly’s adoption of 15 resolutions against Israel as being antisemitic. These resolutions include war crimes in Gaza post-October 7th and settlements in the occupied West Bank. UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has been barred from entering the country over the government’s claim that he failed to fully condemn a missile strike by Iran. Recently Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu spread misinformation on X, stating that Israel was founded through victory in the ‘war of independence’. In reality, Israel was established by the UN in 1948. With this legacy of tension, the recent offensive against UNRWA should not come as a surprise to other foreign powers on the peripheries of this conflict.

Israel’s animosity towards the UN does not exist in isolation but is rather entrenched in a long history of confrontation. The current right-wing coalition government has continually sowed mistrust against the UN

UNRWA’s ousting from Israel has rallied calls of condemnation from many of the nation’s allies. Foreign ministers from Western allies have issued a statement expressing ‘grave concern’ towards the decision. Israel’s continued disregard for international human rights portrays it as an emerging rogue state, risking a pariah reputation among its Western liberal allies, on whom it relies for military aid.

The new Starmer government has only mildly harshened their condemnation of the state’s conduct. On September 2nd, David Lammy announced the suspension of 30 out of 350 arms licenses to Israel but emphasised that this was not an arms embargo and that the UK will continue to stand for Israel’s security. However, this milquetoast attitude has shifted somewhat following the Knesset vote. UK representative to the UN Barbara Woodward has stated that the PM rejects attempts to undermine UNRWA. Furthermore, Annaliese Dodds has said further restrictions against Israel are on the table. This ‘no more excuses’ attitude comes from the $27 million the UK has committed to UNRWA and Mr Starmer’s desire to revitalise the UK’s standing in Europe and the UN as a responsible, influential state actor.

The lack of oversight on Israel has allowed them to continuously neglect the conventions of IHR, perhaps this last infraction is a step too far for the UK. The recent US election results could complicate things however as many wait with bated breath to see Trump’s approach to the Middle East. The UK cabinet has communicated their desire to maintain the ‘special relationship’ regardless of election results, so we may see Mr Starmer bending the knee rather than a divergence in foreign policy.

Image Credit: Wikimedia Commons/ RomanDeckert