The Conservative Party’s relationship with tax cuts
By Alex Owen
With the new government comes a new era of Conservative economic policy. The recently installed Chancellor of the Exchequer Kwasi Kwarteng gave a clear statement of intent as to what this era will entail in his so-called ‘mini-budget’ last week. Kwarteng announced a raft of tax cuts aimed at boosting economic growth and allowing people to keep more of their own money. These measures are wholly consistent with the platform on which the new Prime Minister Liz Truss stood when campaigning to become Leader of the Conservative Party this summer.
The leadership contest was the first time in over a decade the Conservative Party has had the chance to debate in public what it means to be a Conservative. Throughout, there was a broad consensus amongst all candidates that taxes were largely ‘un-Conservative’, and should be avoided where possible. Even Rishi Sunak, who was Chancellor at a time when the UK saw its highest tax burden in 70 years, claimed to be instinctively against high taxes when pitching to be Leader. This is familiar territory for many self-styled ‘fiscal conservatives’, who believe in low taxes and a minimal state, and many would recognise it as classic right-wing economic policy.
Even Rishi Sunak, who was Chancellor at a time when the UK saw its highest tax burden in 70 years, claimed to be instinctively against high taxes
The majority of today’s politicians grew up when the Conservative Party was governed by the economics of Thatcherism. Although this varied throughout her time as Prime Minister, Margaret Thatcher’s economic legacy was that of a preference for a minimal state, and with it (after a period of policies designed to lower inflation), tax cuts. Ever since, the Conservatives have always been ideologically of this disposition. That is until the reshaping of the political landscape by the 2016 vote to leave the European Union, and subsequent 2019 General Election, in which the Conservative Party won over many traditionally working-class Labour voters in the so-called ‘Red Wall’. This partial realignment in voting preferences saw the Conservative Party complete its departure (which begun under Theresa May) from the received Thatcherite wisdom, and move towards the kind of One-Nation Conservatism not seen since the days of Macmillan. With this new agenda came the need for higher borrowing, but also (due to Treasury orthodoxy) higher taxes. The downfall of Johnson led to a return to more conventional Conservative economic policy, and therefore a drive to keep taxes low once again. However, the conclusion that an ideological desire to cut taxes is inherently Conservative is some way off.
Throughout history a desire for low taxes has often gone hand in hand with a preference for free-market economics, whether that be the early revolutionaries of the ‘Boston Tea Party’ in America, the ‘Anti-Corn Law League’ in the early 19th Century, or indeed the aforementioned Thatcher government of the 1980s. Such forces, although today associated with being a ‘true conservative’, in fact run contrary to many traditional conservative values, the most important of which being an antipathy to change. Conservatism, first and foremost, is about conservation, in whatever form that might take. Whilst this does not mean that being in favour of change is impossible for a conservative, it is still a far cry away from the radical, dramatic and sudden changes that can take place within the free market. This is a point that is best expounded by the latest movements in the exchange rates, with the Pound Sterling falling sharply to its lowest level against the US Dollar in over 50 years, resulting in uncertainty and economic instability.
Whilst a lack of taxes can help contribute towards greater volatility, taxes themselves can be used by the government to preserve society as it is. The greater the level of taxation, the greater the government’s power to frustrate forces likely to erode conservative values. Whilst in the post-war era governments used the state apparatus to maintain levels of employment, in the times of Coronavirus we have seen the government using its powers to save lives as well as livelihoods. Such measures are inherently conservative in nature, designed to ensure as little change as possible. None of this would have been able to take place were it not for the power of taxes and the government’s ability to use them as it sees fit, whether that be to promote conservatism or otherwise.
Whilst a lack of taxes can help contribute towards greater volatility, taxes themselves can be used by the government to preserve society as it is.
The new direction of Conservative economic policy is an interesting and radical departure from the Johnson era and pertains to more Thatcherite policy preferences. But the raft of tax cuts unveiled on Friday should be seen as just that, policy preferences. The notion that the Conservative Party is returning to its true values should be treated with suspicion. Although the Conservative government is returning to policies more in keeping with those of the last 40 years, this is not synonymous with a conservative approach to economic governance. It is a dichotomy which perhaps warrants a more in-depth look at the nature of conservatism itself.
Image: HM Treasury via Wikimedia Commons

