The significance of England’s tour to Pakistan: history in the making?

By Felix Turner

The fourth T20 between England and Pakistan in Karachi came to a nail-biting conclusion as Haris Rauf snatched victory for Pakistan, levelling the series in the process. This is England’s first tour to Pakistan since 2005, and the importance of it for both world cricket and Pakistan cannot be understated. 

The reason behind England’s long absence is a tragic one. In 2009, in Lahore, the Sri Lankan team bus was attacked by armed terrorists. Windows were shattered by grenades, shots were fired at the players, and seven Pakistani nationals were killed – namely six policemen and the driver.

Despite the survival of all the Sri Lankan players, the incident sent shockwaves throughout a sport largely untouched by tragedies of this scale. The result of an enquiry from cricket’s governing body, the International Cricket Council (ICC), was to ban Pakistan from hosting any international matches for the following ten years. 

Thus, the return of England is a big moment for Pakistan – 17 years in the making – and the cricket has certainly not disappointed. Finally, many of the big cricket nations feel able to return to the home of greats like Wasim Akram and Imran Khan.

Finally, many of the big cricket nations feel able to return to the home of greats like Wasim Akram and Imran Khan

Alongside England and Australia, New Zealand will also travel to Pakistan this year and Sri Lanka have already toured. On a personal level for the Pakistani players, they have the privilege of playing in front of a home crowd – something the generation of cricketers before them never did.

The crowds have been a wonderful indication of the success of international cricket’s reintroduction to Pakistan. The atmosphere was electric at the National Stadiumas Haris Rauf tore through England’s lower order to seal a famous victory.

 The roar for Babar Azam as he brought up his century in Pakistan’s record chase of 203-0 sounded as though it had been building for 17 years. Those from every walk of life have all embraced the new era of Pakistani cricket with full force. The consequences can only be positive. 

This article ought to be a story of redemption and togetherness in the face of an atrocity, but an all too sad reality exists instead.  Between the 2021 World Cup and the Ashes series in Australia last winter, England were due to have a landmark tour to Pakistan.

This, in turn, would have made them the first of cricket’s ‘big three’ – which includes India, Australia, and England – to play there since 2009. In September, England cancelled their tour. A spokesperson for the ECB claimed the cancellation was for the “mental and physical well-being of the players”. 

This article ought to be a story of redemption and togetherness in the face of an atrocity, but an all too sad reality exists instead

The Covid-19 bubbles enforced by the World Cup and the Australian government undoubtedly took their toll on the England squad. Many, however, were not convinced by this reasoning.

English pundit and former player Ebony Rainford-Brent said, “It just screams of a team that has more power than another”. Former West Indian bowler Michael Holding even referred to it as “Western arrogance”. Their argument was that this was simply another example of one of cricket’s big triumvirate acting in their own interests.

This is not new, or frankly unfounded, criticism. The film Death of a Gentleman (2015) uncovered a significant coverup propagated by senior officials within the Australian, English, and Indian cricket boards.

The film documented how almost all the proceeds of international cricket go to these three nations and showed their interest lay in profit rather than growing and improving the standard of the world game.

 Many advocates for the protection of international players’ mental health supported the decision to cancel on the grounds that the well-being of individuals must be of paramount importance. Alternatively, some have argued that for the ECB in 2021, the tour of Pakistan did not fit their financial plans.

Many decisions made by the ICC portray an institution that has lost contact with its primary aim

Because of its proximity to the Ashes, and a fear of anything going wrong which might affect the substantially greater commercial value of the Ashes tour, they ignored the hard work put in by the Pakistan Cricket Board and cancelled their visit. 

What are the repercussions of such actions for world cricket? Can the international game survive when all the nations outside the ‘big three’ struggle to make ends meet?

 If something does not change, many of the minor nations will not be able to travel abroad for tours. The commercial implications of this aside, should these institutions not be looking to grow the game rather than shrinking it? 

 Many decisions made by the ICC portray an institution that has lost contact with its primary aim: to protect, promote and ensure that the game of cricket is available to anyone who wishes to play it. 

It is certainly a great success for Pakistan that this tour is happening, and no one should dismiss that. But it is rather what did not happen this time last year which is more worrying for the future of truly global cricket.

Image: Ben Sutherland via Flickr