Green hydrogen: just hot air or fuel for the future?

By Rebecca Weir

Amidst the gloom of the global energy crisis, there have been a few glimmers of hope within the energy sector as an implementation of renewables makes significant strides. Last month, it was announced that green hydrogen is expected to fall from a current $5/kg to an average cost of $1.50/kg by 2030, placing it at a competitive price point to non-renewable options. For billionaire and founder of Breakthrough Energy Venture, Bill Gates, driving down the price of clean hydrogen “would be a huge step towards solving the climate crisis.”

August 2022 was also a month of key political developments: the UK doubled its ambitions for hydrogen production to 10 gigawatts by 2030, Canada and Germany sealed their “Green Hydrogen Alliance”, and Singapore announced its commitment to a $540 million hydrogen gas power plant. Progress was clear in the private sector too, notably Amazon making its first purchase of green hydrogen, and the world’s first all-hydrogen railway receiving the green light in Germany – The Coradia iLint.

Whilst hydrogen is already widely used around the world, what makes these recent developments particularly interesting is their ‘green’ association. Depending on the production method, hydrogen can be grey, turquoise, brown, blue, pink, etc. Blue hydrogen, for instance, is produced from natural gas via a process of “steam methane reforming” – hot steam and a catalyst. Carbon emissions are captured and stored underground, meaning this hydrogen production method is ‘carbon neutral’, and hence ‘blue.’ In contrast, grey hydrogen releases waste CO2 and methane emissions. Whilst this places it at a more competitive price point, around 2/3 cheaper than green, it is clearly more problematic from an environmental viewpoint.

That is where the green kind comes in. It differs significantly from the other forms of hydrogen, by virtue of its unique production method and waste products. It is produced using renewable electricity to drive an electrolyser which splits water into hydrogen and oxygen. The gas is burned to produce power, emitting water vapour and warm air only.

According to the World Economic Forum in 2021, there is unprecedented momentum around the world to fulfil hydrogen’s longstanding potential as a clean energy solution. It is evidently an important piece of the energy transition, enabling the decarbonisation of heavy industrial transportation via carbon-neutral “hydrogen cells.”

This also has significant consequences for the development of the entire renewable energy sector, as excess energy from intermittent wind or solar sources can now be converted into hydrogen and stored underground until needed.

Yet, green hydrogen production still presents challenges, which mainly boil down to the cost and concerns around the efficiency of the process. Green hydrogen currently costs $5/kg, which is significantly more expensive in relation to grey hydrogen’s $1.50/kg. Likewise, producing, compressing, storing, and converting back into electricity or mechanical energy is inefficient. Batteries, for instance, return 90% of every joule of energy that you put in, whereas green hydrogen only returns 37%; thus a 63% loss.

Other experts are sceptical that green hydrogen is an immediate next step, arguing instead for the decarbonisation of existing hydrogen demand. For example, this could be the replacing of ammonia from natural gas with green ammonia, rather than replacing natural gas with green hydrogen.

Nonetheless, the technological and political breakthroughs in August 2022 have truly cemented green hydrogen on the map of energy and climate solutions. Whilst this development must also be undertaken alongside improvements in energy efficiency, electrification and renewable power generation growth, green hydrogen is a much-welcomed milestone in our trajectory towards a new decarbonised future.

Image: Sophie Draper