The Conflict of the Consoles
Jack Percival & Ed Owen
Kinect
When Microsoft and Sony weighed in with their original ideas for motion controlled gaming systems in May 2010, it was the Kinect for Xbox 360 that people were getting excited about. Combining multiple cameras with sensors, voice and face recognition the Kinect as a package is revolutionary, tracking 48 points on the player’s body to give a fully immersive experience in the game without the need for a controller.
Like many, I was initially sceptical of the device having seen a number of systems previously which didn’t live up to expectations. The Kinect however, was a refreshingly involving experience and after a short set up process, which involved moving furniture and performing various “dance moves” in front of the sensor it was set up and ready to go. The voice control and face recognition work well and the controlling of the menus and dashboard just holding your hand out in the air had a sense of a scene from a futuristic spy movie. Many of the games involve significant amounts of movement, something which will surprise Wii users who are used to lying on the sofa and controlling games with a flick of the wrist.
Whilst the potential is definitely there with the Kinect and the device itself is an impressive piece of technology, the one element that lets it down is the current lack of games for the device. Most of the current titles are family friendly fun and will let down hardcore gamers. However, as the technology develops the games will come and the infinite possibilities of the device will be explored.
PS Move
The Wii is huge; you can’t watch the television without seeing whatever celebrity popping up, gurning and swinging peripherals about. It’s only natural that Sony would want a piece of that profitable JLS pie, and thus the Move was born.
The reason that I’m insinuating Sony has been copying Nintendo’s homework is this; the Move is so much like the Wii-mote, that one could almost be forgiven for thinking that the Wii had dolled itself up in black and worn a spherical wig. Similar peripherals make for a similar experience.
However, where the Move is triumphs over the Wii is in it’s responsiveness; more specifically in gaging the accuracy of your movements. This is due to the use of the PS Eye webcam that comes in the bundle; it is simply the better motion sensor, able to pick up inertia and precise movement. Whereas wrist-flicking had the same effect as scything across the living room and scaring the cat on the Wii, Move can gage everything precisely, and I must say it makes the gaming far more immersive.
Yet what of the games themselves? Mostly mediocre; either shallow novelties (Start the Party, EyePet) or unneeded integrations of the technology into existing games that didn’t need it (Heavy Rain). Nevertheless one does stand out; Sport Champions. It operates as a high-end Wii Sports, but the precise nature of Move makes it far more engrossing; you’ll definitely notice the difference in the tennis. This is an excellent advert for the Move; it’s a great party game that offers you depth and rewards skill, immersive enough to warrant the hardware’s purchase.

