Reviewed: Midnight In Paris

By Riccardo Liberatore


Perhaps it is inevitable for a filmmaker of Woody Allen’s longevity to become increasingly self-referential. Is the illusion of a perfectly self-sustaining world not indication of a perfectly accomplished style? It is the craftsman’s dream to devise a machine so fine in detail to make even the fantastic (most times successfully so, sometimes not) appear familiar. In Midnight in Paris however, it isn’t clear whether what is on show is Allen’s imagination, his world, or simply a world shaped in his constructed image as slapstick comedian, riotous artist and blue-collar academic.

Midnight in Paris falls neatly into the film genre Woody Allen arguably invented: fantasy-romantic comedy. The plot centres on Gil (Owen Wilson), a lowbrow Hollywood writer with literary ambitions, and his love affair with Paris and various female satellites: his fiancé (Rachel McAdams), his lover from the ‘20s (Marion Cotillard) and his lover from the flea market (Léa Seydoux). Gil, on holiday with his fiancé and her cartoonishly republican (in the George W. sense) parents, prowls around the streets of Paris in search of relief from upper-middle class America only to fall prey to Gertrude Stein’s circle of protégés (Ernest Hemingway, Pablo Picasso to name a couple), the Fitzgeralds (F. Scott and Zelda) and other protagonists of Paris’ art scene in the ‘20s.

So quickly does Gil find both sentimental and professional gratification in his parallel universe (his novel featuring the owner of a memorabilia shop fares well in the company of the past and receives glowing reviews from all those gathered at Stein’s) that he toys with the idea of settling there permanently. The film is full of the trademark plot twists and romantic equivocation (it is never fully clear exactly what or who Gil is courting) typical of Woody Allen’s style and philosophy of love more generally. But whether or not Gil’s character is complex enough to sustain the plot’s intricacy is harder to gauge.

Allen has said that in making Midnight in Paris his aim was to show us the city through his eyes. The film opens with a series of shots of Paris – the Tour Eiffel, l’Arc de Triomphe, Place de la Concorde – much in the style of his iconic tribute to New York in the 1979 film Manhattan. In both films the cities are painted in smooth, wide brushstrokes as the camera seeks to report the wonders of pedestrian life by acting as a bystander. Both focus on the solemnity of the urban landscape and the glamour and excitement of its lights.

Where the sequences mainly differ is in their intensity: the opening to Manhattan was highly original in the way it combined a stylized and romantic vision of the city with an animated introduction by the protagonist. In Midnight in Paris the opening sequence merely sets the scene for it fails to dramatize the character’s psyche in a way that would render him distinctive and succeeds in explaining Allen only through self-citation. It begs the question, what exactly is Woody Allen showing us? Is it New York dressed up as Paris?

In Midnight in Paris, like in most of his more recent films set in European cities, Allen plays the tourist self-consciously. Not only does tourism feature abundantly in the films – Allen’s characters often express the naïve delight in the Old World and its Masters typical of tourists– but it is almost as though what we was on show was a reality program concerning Allen’s experiences as a tourist; cast after cast of internationally-renowned American actors are invited to make guest appearances in what is a diary of his travels.

Nonetheless, the search for novelty brings Allen to rediscover much of what was great in his work – such as his talent for indulging in the work of his favourite writers – and to enlarge on it in original ways. Allen reproduces with great flair Paris in the ‘20s (and during the Belle Époque) and his ironic portrayals of writers and filmmakers such as Hemingway and Luis Bunuel (wonderfully acted by the varied cast) alone are worth the ticket. Allen is fond of saying that he doesn’t think he will be remembered and that he’d rather be forgotten; yet his writing continues to be at the best of times galvanizing and hilarious and even Midnight in Paris remains true to the immortal work of his early days.