Maintaining Aid Through Recession – congratulations to Labour for its international development policies

It is often said that charity begins at home. With Britain’s economy submerged in a deep recession this sentiment has never seemed pithier. And now, emboldened after years of marginalisation, the sceptics of Overseas Development Assistance (ODA) are beginning to sharpen their knives.

ODA comprises of governmental financial flows aiming to promote the economic development and welfare of developing countries. Although it represents a minimal amount of the UK government’s budget, at approximately 0.52% of Gross National Income in 2006, its critics are loud and vociferous. They often have a point too: there are other ways of supporting development.

The criticisms come from two seemingly opposing viewpoints: global ethics and national interest. Pertaining to the former, the UN estimates that nearly a billion people are starving worldwide. Poverty is prevalent and almost half the world’s population live on less than $2 a day without access to clean water or sanitation. Some ODA sceptics have suggested that this situation actually arises because of foreign aid; others say that ODA does nothing to alleviate these inequities and is thus squandering public money.

Some concerns about the quality of aid distribution are justified, but to propose that it is wholly worthless is misleading, dangerous and, at worst, fatal. As Owen Barder, an expert in International Development, retorted about one such sceptic, if she “is wrong, and yet her book convinces enough people that aid should be reduced, then people will die”. The stakes are high.

The sceptics are largely concerned about governance standards. “ODA keeps non-democratic, corrupt and inept regimes in power”, some holler. “The social contract between citizens and government is undermined”, others add. “It cultivates dependency”. Another criticism often levelled is that ODA produces no tangible results.

Not quite. Disbursing aid through governments rather than directly to the people strengthens the social contract; the latter option undermines the authority and credibility of the state. It also lowers transaction costs, streamlines development policies across multiple agencies, and builds the capacities of governments.

The argument that it fosters dependency is startling. There is strong evidence to suggest that aid is correlated with growth, helping to finance better power infrastructures, educational facilities, and transportation and communication systems. Along with this are ‘spill-over’ effects from increases in foreign direct investments, trade volumes and so on.

If anything, ODA helps construct the foundations of a strong economy, enabling developing countries to become self-sufficient in the long term. Moreover, the alternative to aid which the sceptics often propose, – privatisation, liberalisation and de-regulation – in the words of Paul Collier, “exaggerates this opportunity for alternative finance and underestimates the difficulties African societies face”. This has been compounded by the global recession.

Britain’s national interest, the second reason why ODA is deemed irresponsible, is frequently overlooked. Blair’s liberal interventionism may have been discredited following the Iraq War, but the tenets it was founded upon remain as important as ever. With the globalisation of trade, travel and ideas, developments on the other side of the globe can have a profound effect upon Britain’s welfare and security. It is no longer possible to turn inwards.

The outbreak of Swine Flu is a telling example: global action is necessary, but many developing countries lack the resources to take effective measures. If the problem is not solved within these countries, then it is more likely to spread to our isles. Overlooking the welfare of people in poorer countries will therefore be detrimental to our own.

Providing ODA results in positive-sum gains. Helping to give people in Pakistan an education provides them with hopes and aspirations, hence reducing violent tendencies against British interests. Encouraging developing countries to adapt to climate change and adopt sustainable agricultural practices reduces global greenhouse emissions. Preventing food, social and economic crises from deteriorating by offering valuable skills, resources and commodities serves as a powerful form of ‘soft power’, which is the ability to achieve policy aims through the attractiveness of our culture, ideals and policies.

It is for these reasons that the Labour government’s decision not to reduce aid spending in the recent budget should be celebrated. This is particularly significant because The Department for International Development (DFID), created in 1997, is the world’s pre-eminent aid organisation.

Its expertise is needed and sought across the globe and it is up to us to ensure that this continues by putting pressure on future governments not to reduce its funding or independence.

Indeed, the Conservative Party has stated that if they win the next election the Foreign Office will be given more influence over the distribution of ODA. This is a woeful idea which should be firmly opposed, not least because it will undermine DFID and lend credence to the notion of neo-colonialism, especially in those countries to which Britain is historically attached.

The world’s poorest will be the worst affected by the global recession. This is not the time to turn our backs on the commitments we have made. Even if you do not want to do it for the sake of the common good, do it for yourselves.