McBride's Lesson in Media Ethics – we should not overlook the role of journalists in Brown's bullying
The subtext of l’affaire McBride is the acquiescence of journalists in an extremely dodgy political lobby system.
Following the resignation of Brown’s personal attack dog, the commentariat lined up to rip a piece of flesh from the disgraced spin-doctor’s carcass.
Steve Richards of The Independent wrote about a TV presenter being told by McBride to ask a cabinet minister about his drinking problem. Boris Johnson told of McBride’s unpatriotic willingness to sabotage some Olympic-related occasion in the name of undermining the new Tory mayor. Iain Martin of The Telegraph explained McBride’s involvement in the chaotic 3am resignation of Ruth Kelly.
None of this was made public at the time because of the powers wielded by McBride, namely the power to cut journalists off from his briefings and the power to use other journalists to spread poison about opponents. You don’t lightly make enemies with people who have such power, especially if you are a lobby journalist whose job depends on a flow of political stories from ‘anonymous sources’.
Some have dated the origin of the technique of anonymous briefing to the the journalist George Steward, who in the autumn of 1937 spread a strategic lie on behalf of Prime Minister Chamberlain. The foreign secretary, Lord Halifax, was on a trip to Germany, but with no special diplomatic intention in mind. Steward briefed The Times and The Telegraph that the purpose of the meeting was to make appeasing gestures, and thus No. 10 won an internal political struggle against the Foreign Office on the policy question of how to approach Herr Hitler.
Thatcher’s press man, Bernard Ingham, institutionalised the practice and turned it into a science. The good work of Alastair Campbell was the result of the Labour Party, traditionally less efficient and ruthless in such matters, learning to play the same game. It is a system that diminishes the power of the cabinet to hold the Prime Minister to account, with the positive effect – if we view it as a positive – that the government can get more done. Damian McBride and Charlie Whelan are Mr Brown’s somewhat inferior versions of Ingham and Campbell, bullying the press into doing the Prime Minister’s dirty work.
There is an old legal phrase, quo warranto or ‘by what right?’, which people who claim authority should always be expected to answer. When Brown’s admirers are challenged to justify the position of a prime minister who has never been elected, they often reply that it’s a good thing we don’t have an American presidential system: we don’t vote for a leader, we vote for a party. Ignoring for a moment the fact that Brown bullied his way to the top of the Labour party and is regarded by many within it as a liability, this argument is completely undermined by the political lobby system of anonymous briefings.
In America, the president is held to account by Congress much more effectively that any British prime minister is held to account by Parliament. Traditionally in Britain, therefore, the role of the Cabinet has been crucial: the PM, as his title suggests, is supposed to be ‘first among equals’, more team leader than emperor. Yet the authority of Cabinet is profoundly undermined by the Malcolm Tuckers of this world.
Relatively admirable and even loyal ministers like Douglas Alexander and Alastair Darling have recently been victims of Brownite attacks. In other words, Britain has the worst of both worlds: an effectively presidential government with none of the constitutional protections.
Cliques rule the world, but like tyrants they do so in the knowledge that they might be displaced by those outside the loop. The great thing about democracy is that it provides a bloodless mechanism for the process of displacement. But the vigour of this system depends on our being able to continually demand: by what right?
Unless the media gives voice to this question, journalism is just another form of entertainment. When journalists are servile to those with power, they deserve to lose the respect and trust of the public.
There are a lot of other deep problems with the British press. We have the ineffective and illiberal combination of libel law and the Press Complaints Commission; commercial pressures favour cheap journalism which relies on the press releases from authority and also from PR on behalf of businesses and other organisations. Press magnates such as Murdoch have the power to intervene in politics if they so wish.
But what is the point of tackling these distortions if journalists willingly comply with authority?
