Obama's Compromise on Torture – the 44th President needs to be tougher about his liberal principles
Torture is a war crime. The Japanese were tried, convicted, and hung for employing methods of interrogation such as waterboarding against American prisoners of war during WWII.
The Norwegian 1948 war crimes trials convicted Nazi officials on the basis of using ‘enhanced interrogation’, which involved practices such as submitting detainees to near-death freezing conditions, forcing them into prolonged periods of standing, and putting them into stress positions.
Yet these interrogation techniques – which were unequivocally and explicitly denounced as torture around 60 years ago – were reinterpreted by the Bush administration, in what could realistically be described as a political contest to assemble the most radically tough-minded memo on the lack of prisoner rights.
While not only incontrovertibly illegal, and against practically every human rights convention since the Second World War, the simple fact is that torture simply does not work. It’s nothing more than an ineffective, counter-productive, self-defeating, and unethical form of barbarism.
It is no coincidence that one of the most successful military interrogators to have ever lived never resorted to violence. The eye-opening story of the Luftwaffe Officer who procured valuable information from American and British fighter pilots is testimony to the potentially remarkable success of non-violent interrogation. Unsurprisingly, history teaches us that the reliability, effectiveness, and ethics of Hanns-Joachim Scharff is the complete antithesis of those traits which characterise the use of torture.
A revealing example is the case of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed. Waterboarded an astounding 183 times in one month, his admission to the murder of Daniel Pearl was entirely fabricated, and evidently induced by nothing more than sheer agony and unmitigated terror. Perhaps the Bush administration should have spent more time reading history books than watching the (admittedly gripping) television series 24.
The desire of the Obama administration to draw a line under the disastrous human rights abuse and transparent law-twisting of the Bush years is clearly admirable. Yet rather than a firm line, all we have at the moment is a disappointingly half-hearted squiggle.
The underlying flaw in Obama’s carefully balanced position is that it is an appeasement of those who advocate Bush’s absurdly cruel policy of ‘enhanced interrogation’; it continues to support the dismissal of lawsuits concerning allegations of torture, it has effectively invalidated the verdict of the Nuremberg Trials that ‘obeying orders’ is never admissible (in the assurance that CIA interrogators will not be prosecuted), and it is presently more interested in bipartisanship than the prosecution of those who approved harsh interrogation methods. Certainly not the ‘hope’ and ‘change’ which I was anticipating.
However, all is not doom and gloom. In typical fashion, President Obama has been exceedingly cautious in his wording, and has thus left the door open to the genuine possibility of a ‘truth commission’ and a subsequent criminal investigation. Yet the current administration’s attempt to juggle the conflicting balls of human rights and partisanship is erroneous; one clearly needs to be compromised to uphold the other.
The bottom line is that America has taken a massive step towards legitimising the use of torture across the globe, and that accountability is an absolute necessity. No, prosecution will not undo the damage that has been done; the Rubicon has been crossed and the American moral standing has taken such a dent as to be unrecoverable, at least with regards to the foreseeable future.
Yet one step forward will provide at least some compensation for the Bush administration’s eight year backwards run with regards to the complete neglect of international law and arms control efforts – both of which failed to be mentioned in either of the previous administrations’ National Security Strategies. Not to mention the dismissal of the Security Council (with a “we have the inalienable right to enforce the just demands of the world, even if the world overwhelmingly objects” attitude), a full-blown assault on civil liberties, and the firm establishment of the ‘right’ of the United States to engage in preventative war against whomever it sees fit. Compliance with the Third Geneva Convention on the issue of torture is the least Obama can do.
Presidential rhetoric and precarious executive orders are, in this instance, simply not sufficient; those responsible must be finally brought to justice. Without prosecution, the door is left wedged open for any future American president to follow in the footsteps of George W. Bush. Without prosecution, the global legitimisation of torture edges closer to reality. Without prosecution, the recovery of American moral standing is utterly inconceivable.
Obama is certainly correct in stating that the recent years have been a “dark and painful chapter in our history,” yet he is completely off the mark in claiming that this should be a time for “reflection, not retribution”.
It is time to get off the fence, Mr President.
