The Future will be confusing

by Riccardo Liberatore

The online community seems to be torn between utterly despising Miranda July and everything she and her art stand for, and loving her for exactly the same reasons. The debate is polarized, the opposition angry, the language violent. “THIS IS ONE OF THE GREATEST PIECES OF ROMANTIC ARTWORK EVER DONE. MIRANDA JULY REFLECTS THE FORCE OF LOVE AMONG ALL WEIRD AND IMPOSSIBLE THINGS IN SUCH A BEATIFUL, DEEP AND PEACEFULLY WAY THAT MAKES YOU FEEL THE MOVIE BECOME AN EMOTIONAL ORGAN ATTACHED TO YOU WHILE YOU WATCH IT. HUMANITY OWNS A BIG ONE TO MIRANDA”, writes ‘isaiaselcaco’ from the land of YouTube.

‘BEmagiK’ can sort of see where ‘isaiaselcaco’ (from now on caco) is coming from but is not too sure about the whole ‘external organ’ bit when he or she confesses, “This movie was a mindf*ck. Thank God for netflix.” Others however were completely at loss as to what caco saw in July in the first place. One particularly graphic youtube denizen put forward a slightly less flattering interpretation of July’s second and more recent (soon to be released…) feature film, The Future:  “Oh gross, it’s like a hipster threw up on a camera then filmed with it”.
Although the YouTube community is certainly not an authority on cinema, experience suggests that it can be fairly representative of public opinion. When I last watched a July film we started off as a group of five. Within half an hour we had shrunk to three, then two (the third audience member slept through most of it). Why did the film provoke such strong reactions to the point that two relatively well-bred people didn’t feel they could be in the same room as poor old Miranda and the other two felt that dear old July had a lot going for her?

The charges levelled at Miranda were that she – and her partner in The Future – were extremely irritating. Their way of speaking was thought to be affected and annoying, their life unenviable and their pretensions ultimately unoriginal. Why would anyone want to watch (let alone make) a film in which the main characters succeed at nothing, in which a lot of what they do is ‘dull’ and a lot of what they say (leaving aside a few funny comments) is ‘pathetic’ or, to say the least, of small consequence and little insight?

What is Miranda July trying to do here if not glamorize what is in fact a very depressing reality by insisting that it is so uniquely “WEIRD AND IMPOSSIBLE”? Is Miranda just a no-talent hippy who survives, in fact thrives, thanks to the charity of mother capitalism, of the economic system of action and hard work, sustained only by the admiration and loyalty of a self-loathing and culturally effeminate minority who suffer from a macroeconomic Oedipal complex?

Miranda July has asked me to tell you she is a lot more than that. Her dialogues are not pretentious  – although the trailers (especially that of Me and You and Everyone We Know) which disguise her films as romantic comedies make them appear exactly that – because they are heartfelt to the point of being uncomfortably unfashionable at times.
Take for instance her partner’s dialogue with the moon in The Future just before his suspicion that his girlfriend has in fact cheated on him is confirmed. Is it pretentious for a man to engage in dialogue with the moon? Yes, probably. Does it still appear pretentious when the room seems to freeze in the moon’s light and the main character pleads to be delivered from the awful confrontation that is bound to follow, to escape his so-called ‘alternative’ reality, when the moon speaks to him in the voice of an old man he has befriended and who he sees as some sort of future projection of himself and when all this is done without any attempt at eloquence? It is heartfelt because it wants to be nothing more than what it is – a moment of anxiety, of self-doubt, of change – and because it makes sense in the context of the film.

July does not confirm to the stereotypes of indie filmmakers. She doesn’t present us with an “alternative” and “culturally subversive” reality, but with an alternative and culturally subversive imagination. Her films don’t document a world that is better because different from mainstream society. In Me and You and Everyone We Know the final catharsis is not that of the underdog who has finally found satisfaction for her eccentricities but of an artist who succeeds in giving concrete and realistic expression to her vision, that of a world in which a person like the main character can be expected to be happy.

In The Future it is personal dissatisfaction as experienced by an original and exciting mind that is on show, not the exciting and original world of the dissatisfied. Miranda July would like me to ask you to give her films a go. If not for me, do it for caco.