The Ceasefire under strain? Risk of escalations in the Israel-Gaza conflict

By Tess Cato

Donald Trump’s 20-point peace plan, for which he had been dubbed ‘the peace president’ by the White House, has not been the plain sailing process that he envisioned when he declared himself the most deserving of the Nobel Peace Prize in November. Since Israeli and Hamas delegates signed the first phase of the plan in Egypt this September, both sides have accused each other of breaching their terms. Hamas have accused Israel of carrying out more than a hundred ceasefire violations, and of rejecting aid requests from NGOs in the region (an accusation likewise reported by the United Nations). Similarly, Israel have accused Hamas of killing Israeli soldiers in Rafah, of crossing the withdrawal line set in the peace plan, and of failing to return the remains of Israeli hostages. The latest breaches have been reported inside the Gaza strip, with medics working there reporting the deaths of two children, as a result of Israeli air strikes on the Palestinian town of Bani Suheila on 28th November. With the ceasefire under clear strain, Trump’s peace plan has, so far, proven its impotence in effectively ending the conflict once and for all.

It is not altogether surprising. Though backed by Netanyahu, Hamas was critical of Trump’s deal. One of the points within the deal states that, upon successful ceasefire, the US will deploy a temporary International Stabilisation Force (ISF) to monitor security inside Gaza. Hamas was sceptical of the ISF, predicting it would turn into a ‘party in favour of the occupation [of Gaza by Israel]’. Since President Trump has revealed on many occasions that the US is an ally of Israel, it is not surprising that Hamas would be suspicious of an American-deployed force in Gaza. Furthermore, in October Netanyahu stated on an Israeli TV interview that the war will not end until the disarmament of Hamas and the demilitarisation of the Gaza Strip. With Hamas still armed and active in the region and the ISF seeming unfavourable to Hamas, both sides are still hostile to one another.

”With Hamas still armed and active in the region and the ISF seemingly unfavourable to Hamas, both sides are still hostile to one another”

The conflict extends beyond Gaza itself. The day after 7th October 2023 – the Hamas-led attacks on Southern Israel that kickstarted the war – the Shia Muslim militant group and political party based in Lebanon, Hezbollah, began firing rockets and missiles at Israeli positions. This led to the latest spate of conflict between Hezbollah and Israel, which has been sporadically occurring since 1982, after Israel’s invasion of southern Lebanon during the Lebanese Civil War. Declaring upon its official formation in 1985 that its confrontations with Israel will only end when Israel ceases to exist, Hezbollah is a staunch ally of Hamas. Both groups are declared terrorist organisations by the United Kingdom. In an attempt to wipe out Hezbollah, Israel have launches a series of strikes on Lebanon, killing over 4,000 people, including civilians, and displacing over a million.

In November 2024, a US and France-brokered ceasefire aimed to put an end to the Israeli-Lebanese conflict. However, currently, Israel occupies five small, strategic areas of southern Lebanon, insisting its deployment of troops there is defensive against the threat of Hezbollah-led attacks. Lebanese president Joseph Aoun vehemently opposes the occupation, arguing that Netanyahu is violating the agreement between Lebanon and Israel. Furthermore, on 23rd November Israel killed a senior member of Hezbollah, Haitham Ali al-Tabtabai, in Beirut, a week before striking the Shia Muslim village of Froun, though Israel says it was targeting Hezbollah only, not civilians. President Netanyahu says that Hezbollah have been working to rebuild its military, thus accusing them of breaching the ceasefire and self-justifying his own violations of the truce. While that may be true, the fact remains that Netanyahu appears wholly unwilling to adhere to the terms of the ceasefire he signed with the nation of Lebanon, not with the militant group of Hezbollah.

”President Netanyahu says that Hezbollah have been working to rebuild its military, thus accusing them of breaching the ceasefire”

So with President Trump’s peace plan appearing evermore redundant in the face of continuing fighting in the Gaza Strip and beyond, what’s next for the region? Is Trump still able to put an end to the conflict, as he declared confidently only a few months ago, or will the continuing determination of Israel and Hamas to resist one another – and any group associated with the other – override any attempt to achieve peace? Unfortunately, it seems increasingly unlikely that peace will be achieved any time soon.

Image: Jaber Jehad Badwan via Wikimedia Commons