Canada elects Mark Carney as PM: what’s next for Canada’s relationship with the US?
By Tess Cato
On Tuesday came the news of the Canadian Liberal Party leader Mark Carney’s triumph in the Canadian election, a win fuelled by a national reaction to Donald Trump’s description of Canada as the 51st American state. Though the Liberal Party, led previously by Justin Trudeau, had been losing popularity, Carney’s focus on foreign security – especially in relation to Trump’s threats to Canadian sovereignty – as well as his liberalism, which opposes Trump’s right-wing populism, gave Carney the upper hand.
The Canadian Conservative leader Pierre Poilievre, on the contrary, made only limited references to Trump and instead focused his campaign on domestic affairs – affairs which seem trivial in comparison to the threat to Canada’s existence on the map. According to a survey carried out by the BBC, only around 10% of the Canadian population thought Trump’s threat to Canada was not completely absurd, and in no doubt was this the biggest factor in Carney’s win. Some could say that Trump essentially shot himself in the foot by describing Canada as the 51st US state. So why did he say it? Does he genuinely believe that, in the next four years, he could replace the maple leaf with the stars and stripes?
Let’s get one thing clear: Trump loves to exaggerate, and moreover, he loves to cause a reaction, ruffle feathers, and keep his name constantly in the papers. We saw this with the infamous press conference in the White House in February between Trump, JD Vance and Ukrainian president Zelenskyy. Do Trump and Vance really believe in their claim that Zelenskyy is responsible for starting a war with Russia in which over 46,000 of his own people have died?
Trump and his political cronies are fully aware of who invaded who in February 2022, but during that Black Mirror style press conference, Trump and Vance knew exactly which buttons to press to cause Zelenskyy to react so defensively. Anyone would become increasingly angry at accusations of starting a war that in fact started with the invasion of one’s own country and would become angrier still if these accusations were broadcast on the world stage by two of the world’s most influential men. But the statement still stands: Trump wanted a reaction out of Zelenskyy and boy did he get it. The classic technique of the schoolyard bully.
Let’s get one thing clear: Trump loves to exaggerate, and moreover, he loves to cause a reaction, ruffle feathers, and keep his name constantly in the papers
Trump uses this technique of essentially winding up his opponents over and over again. For example, calling Zelenskyy, the man fighting the Russian dictatorship, a “dictator”; or accusing Kamala Harris of “viciously and violently” overthrowing Joe Biden to become the 2024 presidential candidate for the Democrats. In fact, there is a whole Wikipedia page dedicated to all of the false things Trump has said.
Elon Musk, a key figure in the Trump administration, has tried his hand at this technique too, namely in January of this year when he accused Kier Starmer’s Labour government of tyranny for rejecting a national inquiry into the grooming and rape of young girls in England by a group of South Asian men. Does Musk actually believe that the UK, along with dictatorships such as Russia, is led by a tyrannical government, or did he merely wish to poke at Starmer, cause upheaval in the UK and turn the many devout Republicans against this centre-left government? One would be naïve to think that the current Trump administration genuinely believes in the moral integrity and truth of its statements.
Trump’s methods were no different during the run up to this year’s Canadian election. Along with the question of the 51st state, Trump called Trudeau, who, had been PM since 2015, a mere “governor”. This evidently stirred up anger within Canadians, with one voter phoning Jeremy Vine’s radio show, arguing that Trump has “no idea what he’s talking about”. However, with analysis of Trump’s methods of attacking and winding up his opponents, it’s clear he knows exactly what he’s doing.
By attacking the Canadian Liberal Party and threatening Canadian sovereignty, Trump causes upheaval within the Canadian people, gets his name on the front of every newspaper, and forces Canadians to ask themselves ‘is a 51st state really possible?’. And when they begin to imagine it, they may begin to toe the line. This is exactly the method Trump employed with the imposition of tariffs in April. Despite originally placing tariffs of up to 50% on duty exports to the US, Trump made a U-turn on 9th April, announcing that nations that did not place any retaliatory tariffs on the US would now face a blanket tariff of 10% until July. When asked about this U-turn, Trump simply responded that “people were jumping out of line” and getting “yippy”, clearly instructing all world leaders that he rewards those who don’t challenge him.
Time will tell if Carney toes Trump’s line. It’s clear that the Canadian incumbent will under no circumstances agree to the Americanisation of Canada. But how far will he allow himself to be pushed by Trump, who has his eye firmly set on Canadian resources?
Image: Faculty of Public and Global Affairs/ Wikimedia Commons

