The Epstein Affair continues: Congress clears vote to release the files

By Tobias Gumm

On the 18th of November, the US Congress passed a bill compelling the Department of Justice to release its files on Jeffrey Epstein, clearing easily with 427 votes to one. Clay Higgins, a Republican representative, must have missed the memo as the sole vote against the motion.

With a flurry of new emails released by the House committee, the pressure was mounting on Trump. Even lashing out at Marjorie Taylor Green and other republicans supporting the bill would not stem the tide. Faced with a harrowing defeat in Congress Trump executed a swift U-turn, urging Republicans to release the Epstein files because “we have nothing to hide”.

This sudden reversal is more indicative of his loosening grip on the Republican party. Attacks on Thomas Harold Massie and Marjorie Taylor Green fell short of stopping the momentum behind the bill. In most instances his loyal base would usually follow his lead, this time they stopped short. Worse for Trump his attacks instead provoked many right-wing influencers to speak out, in a bid to avoid defeat in Congress the President backed down. He signed the bill into law on the 20th of November.

”With a flurry of new emails released by the House committee, the pressure was mounting on Trump”

So, what can the public expect to see in the Epstein files?

The release refers to the files collected by the DoJ in the two major criminal investigations into Jeffery Epstein from 2006 to 2019. Infamously the first criminal investigation ended in 2008 with a controversial plea deal. Evidence is set to include details of police investigations, physical documents seized at properties, and transcripts of witness testimony. Those looking for information on Epstein’s connections may be disappointed, with the focus of the investigations looking at what happened to the victims rather than personal connections.

We can expect any released DoJ files to heavily redact any information relating to victims. Additionally, the DoJ can withhold documents that could ‘jeopardise’ ongoing investigations (coinciding with a new investigation ordered by Trump on key Democrats associated with Epstein). Crucially, this power is limited provided the restriction is “narrowly tailored and temporary”. Regardless the likelihood that this will bring a satisfactory close to the case is unlikely. Instead, we may see further speculation about coverups, involvement, and betrayal.

The jury is still out, for a President with nothing to hide the struggle to release DoJ files through a Democrat-led bill leaves a sour taste. Donald Trump has long been plagued by his personal links to Jeffrey Epstein, indeed earlier this year after campaign claims of releasing the files his own attorney-general Pam Bondi stated that no ‘client list’ existed. After years of drilling up the conspiracy theories around Jeffrey Epstein the current administration must be regretting its role in the frenzy. Such voters currently feel betrayed; feeling that the administration has failed to reveal the ‘truth’.

”The DoJ can withold documents that could ‘jeopardise’ ongoing investigations”

Trump continues to escalate the tension around Epstein theories, most recently claiming that well-known Democrats are “deeply associated”, outlining his latest tactic, to allege that Epstein was more involved with Democrats than Republicans. This is a shift from Trump’s earlier approach of dismissing the scandal, a sign of the building public frustration. Democrats continue to push the scandal having finally found a pressure point Republicans are unhappy with. Polling by YouGov earlier this year states over 80% of Democrats and half of Republicans believe the government is covering up evidence about Epstein.

With few facts to be found in the awaited release, Trump should not be surprised if the spotlight circles back to his own involvement. Framing the scandal as just a “Democrat problem” has been slow to pick up support outside his supporter base. For now, the bill forces the attorney-general to release DoJ files in a 30-day window.

Image: United States Department of Justice via Wikimedia Commons