The case of the ‘benefits scroungers’
By Jade Azim
Earlier in January, Channel 4 broadcasted a programme entitled Benefits Street, a contribution to what some have called a growing trend in ‘Poverty Porn’ that includes the earlier ‘Oscar-worthy; production We All Pay Your Benefits from those left-leaning chaps at the BBC.
These are almost direct print-to-screen adaptations of headlines from popular tabloids which seem to have a fast-functioning moving belt system that coughs out sensationalist stories about mothers on benefits living in mansions which bare next to no relation to the reality of the many millions scraping by on Job Seeker’s Allowance (JSA), at a time where jobs are few and far between and when actually available, offer wages that fall far below the recommended living wage.
This trend has, to much surprise, coincided with similar rhetoric from those other chaps in Westminster. Indeed, George Osborne has ‘spoken out’ about “the shift worker, leaving home in the dark hours of the early morning, who looks up at the closed blinds of their next-door neighbour sleeping off a life on benefits.”
His later reference to “hardworking people” can roughly be translated as “not unemployed” and most certainly “not claiming benefits”, reflecting a long-standing tradition of pitting the working poor against the unemployed poor, who have become scapegoats in a long list (beneath immigrants and pregnant teenagers) used to shroud tax evaders and banks in smoke and mirrors.
According to polls by YouGov, four out of ten people think benefits are too generous and three in five believe the system has created a culture of dependency. However, people who know the least about the facts are the most hostile towards claimants: more than half of those who were least informed believed benefits are too generous, while fewer than one in three of those giving the most informed and accurate answers agreed with benefits.
Frances O’Grady, the Trade Union Centre General Secretary, said: “It is not surprising that voters want to get tough on welfare. They think the system is much more generous than it is in reality.” Apparently this falsehood not only poisons public opinion, but determines our social and economic policy which, according to O’Grady, is conducted on the same “basis of prejudice and ignorance.”
As Ministers and the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) use this demonisation to justify their slashes to the benefits system, especially after Osborne recently announced a further cut of £25 billion to welfare, many experts have in fact questioned whether these cuts are the only possible ‘tough choice’ Osborne could make to meet deficit targets. Many alternatives involve raising taxes in areas in which – surprise, surprise – Tory voters and donors make up a steadfast population.
Among the potential alternatives are a “Robin Hood Tax” of 0.05 per cent on banks’ financial transactions which could raise up to £20 billion a year, cutting the tax relief of wealthy pensioners that could earn the state another £1.8 billion; implementing the Lib Dem and Labour backed Mansion Tax which would put a one per cent rise on properties worth more than £2 million and raise £2 billion a year; and the most notorious, cracking down on tax evasion which costs £35 billion, according to the HM Revenues & Customs.
And yet, these alternatives are rarely spoken about in a public forum, least of all are they the focal point of a vast array of documentaries. In fact, it would seem that where the elite cost the state an excess amount of money – in most cases billions more than the three per cent of the welfare budget spent on Job Seeker’s Allowance – there seems to be very little in the way of transparency or exposure. There are certainly no documentaries called ‘Banker’s Street’ or indeed ‘We All Pay For Your Tax Evasion’.
Similarly, there are no documentaries for the complete opposite of the spectrum either; there is no documentary insight into the 400,000 now using food banks, a number that has swelled under welfare cuts.
So how is it, then, that we as a nation can stand by while JSA which accounts for three per cent of the DWP’s budget suffers 100 per cent of the negative media attention?
It is often said that you can judge a nation by how it treats its poor. Unfortunately the prognosis for the UK does not seem too bright.
Photograph: Patrick Jordan

