How will Durham be coloured in May?
By Jade Azim
May’s election is impossible to call. With polling showing Labour and The Conservatives neck and neck, both at around 30-34%, and smaller parties presenting a threatening insurgency to the (previously) Big Three, the national picture is obscured by ambiguity and a stunning lack of inevitability.
However, the picture at seat-level is much easier to read, and can provide a much better insight into the swing of this election. Lord Ashcroft is infamous for his detailed polling in marginal seats, and the marginal swing tends to result in the same picture: relative Tory decline, Ukip incline, and the collapse of the Lib Dems.
In 2010, it was the latter that was the most cause for concern for the Labour Party incumbent Roberta Blackman-Woods MP. Durham had been a safe Labour seat since 1935. 2010 was unique in the sky-high polling the Lib Dems incurred at the peak of ‘Cleggmania’. You know, when Clegg was a popular figure. In 2010, Blackman-Woods and her team faced a real moment of scepticism in holding the seat, which would have been a historical turning point for a constituency previously considered to have ‘safe’ status for Labour. Durham became vulnerable in part because the Liberal Democrats have always polled in second place, thanks to significant support in the city itself, which is far more prosperous than the surrounding mining communities and otherwise comparatively deprived County Durham. So with the student population in support of Clegg’s tuition fee pledge, it looked to be a good target for the surging party.
But alas it was not to be. As the popularity of the Liberal Democrats waned, Roberta Blackman-Woods won with a comfortable 3,000 vote majority- an increase in support since the 2005 election. Both the Lib Dem and Labour vote actually decreased their share by 2.1% and 2.9% respectively.
This was in part due to the significant but not game-changing increase in the Conservative vote in 2010 by 3.9%, although as always the Conservatives have not and will not get a see-in in a region that has been historically hostile to them, particularly since the Miners’ Strike of 1984-5. It was in fact in 2005 when the Lib Dems saw their greatest growth in this constituency, where there was a 16.1% increase in Lib Dem support in the waning years of Blair.
Nevertheless, the 2010 election was an anxious one for Labour in Durham City, full of unprecedented uncertainties under a youth-led and affluent city-dwelling yellow banner that seemed to represent an unstoppable tide, albeit eventually proving vastly overstated.
2015 will tell a very different story for the constituency. The Lib Dems surge will likely collapse, as with the national picture, and particularly at the mercy of students should they turn out. Clegg’s infamous tuition fees broken promise will mean Cleggmania will certainly not make a return in student cities, although the student voting base has clearly proven unreliable as an indicator of the swing. This is why the student-led ‘Green Surge’ has not been discussed in this article that has never been much hope for the Greens before –the best they have done is 1.8% of the vote.
Instead, the biggest new threat to Labour’s incumbency is Farage’s UKIP in the neighbouring miner’s communities, where white working class voters may decide purple is the new red. Indeed, while there are still remaining but confined affluent yellow wards in the cobbled streets of historic Durham, and extremely loyal red wards in the less affluent bordering towns, the threat of Farage ‘parking his tanks on Labour’s backyard’ may inflict notable damage on Labour’s hegemony where it should otherwise be restored after the tumultuous past few years.
But compared to Stockton South and Redcar, the real marginal seats in these parts, Durham City should remain a hold for Labour. Labour will come first, with a decreased share, but
Durham City will remain red nonetheless. While technically it is a semi-marginal, 2015 should see it regain its ‘safe’ status from the turbulent elections of 2005 and 2010. It is predicting the order after that that remains problematic and curious. It could be that UKIP may come a close second, knocking the Lib Dems off their vigorously held position, if the villages surrounding the City outnumber the affluent wards in the City centre. Perhaps the most interesting race will therefore be who will win the silver medal, and how close that silver could be to turning gold in the future.
Either way, Roberta Blackman-Woods MP will likely go into this election with less concern than five years prior, her enemies now possibly divided, but nevertheless not risking complacency amid the threat of a Labour to UKIP swing that could see the margin of her majority decreased although very unlikely depleted.
Photograph: www.twitter.com, @robertabwMP
Illustation: Creative Commons

