MPs honoured in £250,000 portraits
The media is in uproar after it has emerged that £250,000 of public money has been spent on portraits of MPs, an affair that has been labelled an ‘expensive vanity project’.
Conservative, Labour and Liberal Democrat representatives have all sat for paintings, splashing four and even five-figure sums for each commission.
Now we can add ‘portraits’ to our list of MPs’ extravagant expenses, along with a £1,645 ‘floating duck island’ and £380 worth of horse manure. Ladies and gentlemen, here we have Paintgate.
Yes, a quarter of a million pounds is an eye-wateringly expensive sum during this time of austerity, and yes, the money could be better spent on public artworks or projects. But spending money on artwork cannot be compared to spending money on cute garden features. Unlike Sir Peter Viggers’s Duck House, portraits are an important part of British history.
A spokesperson for Parliament said that the collection aimed to record “those who have made a significant contribution to UK political life over the centuries”. In England, historically important people are celebrated by being painted and stuck on a wall, and as a proud democracy we ought to continue the tradition of applauding our politicians for the work they do.
In general, MPs are not money-driven monsters on a power trip, but the recent expenses scandal has certainly given them a bad name.
It should be noted that the annual salary for an English MP is £66,396; a figure that seems insignificant in contrast to the pay packets received by other professionals such as bankers. Compared to worldwide leading democracies, English MPs are in fact paid very little: Australian parliamentarians earn almost double that of an English MP and those in Japan earn two and a half times that figure.
The current climate is less than friendly towards politicians in light of the expenses scandal (I wouldn’t blame MPs for emigrating to Japan, or even Australia), and many voters feel that the current system has been undermined by politicians misusing their expenditures. Therefore the paintings of MPs might be better used as a way to promote a positive image of the people who strive to make the country a better place.
If it worked – albeit temporarily – for the painfully unpopular Charles I, maybe George Osborne has a glimmer of hope. Maybe. Placing portraits in public areas of an MP’s constituency such as libraries and town halls would demystify politicians and forge a vital connection between the people and their representatives.
The problem here is that these portraits are placed inside the Houses of Parliament, visible only to a select few. In the grand scheme of government spending, £250,000 is a small amount of money; the heart of the issue is that the portraits are sheltered from the public eye.
We have preserved our rulers on canvas for thousands of years, but as Jonathan Isaby, chief executive of the Tax Payers Alliance argues, “when photographs are so much cheaper than paintings, politicians need to think twice about immortalising themselves on canvas”.
From an economic perspective this argument is relevant, but the point of portraiture is not to capture a photorealistic image but to preserve the essence of a sitter’s personality. The medium of photography does not necessarily allow for the allegorical and symbolic possibilities so central to portraiture.
Whilst photography captures a mimetic representation, paintings offer a richer spectrum for analysis and better reflect the relationship between artist and sitter. Portrait paintings are an integral part of British cultural heritage which should be maintained.
Photograph: Derek Key

