The attacks of Islamic State should not be considered religious
By Christopher Akka
On November 13th 2015, Paris experienced synchronised attacks, killing 130 and injuring countless more. A few months later, on 22nd March 2016, Brussels suffered similar attacks, killing over 30 and injuring hundreds. The Islamic group IS later claimed responsibility. For the group, the attacks were carried out by religious fundamentalists bent on turning the world towards Allah, and their view of the ‘correct’ way of thinking. In truth, however, they were more ideological than religious. Brussels was attacked for revenge, Paris was attacked for its hedonistic culture. Both are linked, but neither was truly religious.
The press and public gave considerable credence to the idea that these attacks were religious. According to some, IS is ‘fundamentalist’. The anthropologist Berger described two different types of fundamentalism. The first he labels ‘defensive’. Groups that fall into this category disagree with the values that society as a whole holds, and so shut themselves off from it. This can be seen in the Amish community today. The second is ‘offensive’. This, arguably, describes IS. Those in this category believe that society outside their group is wrong, and that it is their duty to demonstrate the ‘truth’. IS would argue that by launching attacks they are showing that Allah is the one true god. Urubshurow, too, talks of ‘Revivalist muslims’, who “advocate eliminating many elements of local cultures” and are actively against much of the “poisonous Western cultural elements perceived as infiltrating Muslim life”. IS, therefore, is a ‘religious fundamentalist‘ group.
But this does not necessarily mean that the attacks themselves were ‘religious’. In their message of responsibility for the Paris attacks, IS open with a quote directly from a religious text, centring the attacks in religion. Similarly, throughout the message, they include references to “Allah’s peace and blessings”. For them, certainly, the attacks were religious. They were carried out by people who believed that what they were doing was just in the eyes of their god. When another ‘fundamentalist’ group is examined, however, such a claim seems to lose credibility. In 2013, the leader of Al Qaeda “stated that Al Qaeda operatives should avoid attacks that could inadvertently cause the death of Muslim civilians and noncombatant women or children”. In the Charlie Hebdo attack in January 2015, Al Qaeda targeted specific individuals, in a carefully organised strike. This is completely different to IS’ attacks in both November and March, where the goal was seemingly to cause as much damage as possible. That the IS attackers did not seem to have any regard for who they were killing, whether they be Muslim, women or children, suggests that they are not acting within the guidelines found in the Quran, which certainly does not condone the killing of other Muslims, unless they embrace another religion. Although IS would claim that that any non-IS Muslim is an ‘apostate’ (a person who renounces a religious belief) and should be killed, although this seems to be more of an ideological rather than religious distinction.
Therefore, we should perhaps not consider this attack as ‘religious’ at all. When a similar attack is conducted by a Christian, we look for further issues, such as the mental state of the perpetrators or their family background. Anders Breivik claimed some sort of religious motivation for the 2011 Norway killings, but this was largely glossed over by the press. Why then do we not try and disassociate religion from all attacks, especially when studying the motives behind them? Surely the fact that these attacks were carried out by Muslims does not mean that they should be treated any differently?
Further, the majority of Muslims do not support the attacks. One particularly poignant tweet states that “Gunmen were heard shouting ‘Allahu Akbar’ but I did the same tonight, in my room, praying for those killed & their families”. Many Muslims have separated their faith from that of the attackers, claiming that they are not of the same religion. Pope Francis too, has condemned similar attacks, stating that the Charlie Hebdo attackers based their actions on “deviant forms of religions”. Although they may go as far as to believe that what they are doing is religiously acceptable, their view has been corrupted.
This is my opinion. The very fact that there are so many more non-violent Muslims than violent ones suggests that there is some sort of twisted reading of the texts on the behalf of the attackers in justifying their actions. Not only this, but Islam is derived from the word ‘salaam’, which means ‘peace’. An attack surely cannot be religious, if the religion it is purporting to be in the name of is based on such a concept. IS themselves do not appear to cite explicit religious reasons for the attacks. There is no mention that they felt told by Allah to carry out the killings, or even an explicit reference to the Quran (save the very beginning which quotes an indirect reference to non-believers converting). This statement is, in fact, only religious because it constantly refers to them acting for Allah, without any further backing.
It would be fairer to say that it was more of an ideological attack—one group attacked another in an attempt to highlight the errors in its culture. Indeed, IS claimed that Brussels was attacked as it was “a country participating in the international coalition against the Islamic State”—this is not religious, this is revenge. The twitter hashtag ‘TerrorismHasNoReligion’ emphasises that the attacks should not be considered religious at all. What is perhaps most interesting about these attacks however, is how they have united the world behind religion. Support for Muslims has never been so strong after a terrorist attack, and the hashtags ‘PrayForParis‘ and ‘PrayForBelgium’ have emerged, bringing people together through the religious concept of prayer. The world has been brought together over the topic of religion, despite what IS had hoped for.
Image: Wikimedia via Creative Commons
