Islamic State: A defence
By Christopher Akka
The response to my article on the Paris and Brussels attacks raised some interesting points but also contained a number of inaccuracies that I wish to address.
The author referred to several ‘facts’ which do not withstand scrutiny. For example, she writes that “the Quran does not explicitly suggest that non-Muslims should be killed”. A quick Google, however, would produce results that stated otherwise (an explicit example being 47:3-4: “So when you meet those who disbelieve [in battle], strike [their] necks, until you have inflicted slaughter on them”). The claim that “Islam has remained unchanged since the 13th century” could be debated at length, and might be better suited to an article in itself (or a journal!). Similarly, the statement that articles like mine are “stunting debates on religious extremism” seems a little odd given that it has provoked one. The author’s point that “religion is difficult to define… hence we cannot define it clearly so how can you allude to what is religious or not?” appears to negate her entire subsequent argument that the attacks are religious . Claims such as “religion was invented [emphasis added] in times before reason and science” perhaps betrays the author’s anti-religious bias in her response as a whole.
It is worth restating my original argument, which seems not to have been addressed by the response. This point is that although IS are a religious group, the attacks in Paris and Brussels in particular were not religious themselves.
The author begins by agreeing that “not all terrorist attacks are religious.” Where we differ, however, is in the claim that IS’ attacks are religious, because of the “nature of their [IS’] beliefs”. This ignores the fact that the letters of responsibility for both Paris and Brussels cited explicitly non-religious reasons and, in fact, provide little religious backing for the attacks. Despite this, the response article suggests that they are nevertheless religious as the group that perpetrated them is a ‘religious’ group.
Perhaps it is useful to give an example. Suppose a furniture shop is bombed by a group of religious extremists, purely because they believed that the winter collection of sofas did not fit in with the ‘vibe’ of their HQ. DFS subsequently comes out in support of the shop, claiming that it would do anything to help, and as a result, it too is targeted by the extremists. I highly doubt that anyone would call these attacks explicitly ‘religious’. Granted, the example is far fetched, but I feel it portrays the situation adequately. A religious group targeted Paris expressly because of differing morals (“a city of prostitution”)—it did not ‘fit in’ with what they felt was right. Belgium came out in support, later capturing one of the perpetrators, and subsequently it too was bombed (although admittedly the reason behind this was a little more complex, but still, not explicitly ‘religious’). Surely one must admit that even a fundamentalist religious group can carry out actions for non-religious reasons? In the author’s own words, “terrorism is a tactic not a tool”—IS are not, in these particular attacks, using terrorism as a conveyor of their religious message; it is a tactic for revenge and is a result of disagreements in culture.
To suggest that I am an “apologist for Islamophobia” is far-fetched: I agree wholeheartedly that IS’ attacks on churches in the middle east, for example, are religious. I do not, however, feel that the West is “lack[ing] understanding” when it comes to these debates. Many of the world’s leading Islamic scholars are from the West. Yes, I may be “trying to not tar an entire religion”, but that is only because I do not feel that an entire religion needs to be tarred in the first place.
Photograph: Jasper Cox
