Durham CU: Should it present Christianity in a more positive light?
By Christopher Akka
Let me begin this article by stating, from the outset, that I am a Christian—I go to church, I pray, but I’m not part of DICCU, although find much of their work admirable.
Having read this article, I agree that the CU should aim to incorporate everyone who identifies as a Christian, as opposed to focussing on certain practices. Creating an environment where, despite their best efforts to ‘make anyone welcome’, Christians such as myself feel uncomfortable, seems to be going against Jesus’ teachings on love and inclusion—something key to our faith. But this is not where my concern lies. No—my concern is found in what some perceive to be the emphasis of their mission to non-believers.
Speaking to friends from all different backgrounds, it quickly became apparent that many had similar issues with the CU. One felt he was told that he would “go to hell” if he didn’t convert. Now I understand that this may well have been hyperbolic on his part, but I can see his issue. Having been to several CU events, such as the majority of their STORY mission week (which on the whole, I found both fascinating and extremely well-organised, prompting interesting and important discussions), it seemed that the speakers were using ‘scare-tactics’ in order to spread their message. When asked if a young girl, brought up in IS controlled Syria and killed in an air strike, would receive eternal life, one speaker answered that if she did not accept Jesus, then no, she wouldn’t, before seemingly changing topic to how we, ourselves now have the chance to convert, and so this issue should not affect us.
Not only did I personally believe this to be wrong (the girl likely would never have even heard of Jesus), but I was shocked by his answer. This is not a religious truth. It is an opinion. What he should have said is that no one knows. Yes, the Bible contains verses that suggest this, but just as many can be found that suggest otherwise. It is not our place to voice our own personal opinions as the general consensus of Christianity, as he seemed to be doing. In fact, student CU members around the country represent only around 10% of all student Christians.
A similar story can be found at the CU Carol Service last academic year, with the take home message seeming to be that if one did not convert, one would be eternally punished. The same speaker more recently gave a talk that even my friends in the CU were angry about, stating that they were happy that none of their friends had come on that particular night— the wrong message was coming across.
Even the UCCF (the CU governing body) doctrinal basis contains negative language: the word “sin” appears seven times in 11 points, with point 8 stating that “The Holy Spirit alone makes the work of Christ effective to individual sinners, enabling them to turn to God from their sin and to trust in Jesus Christ.”, instantly branding non-believers as sinners—a word that many such people would find both offensive and un-inviting. There is little mention of the love that Jesus focussed on in his teachings. Similarly, where is a mention of the unity of Christians that this body seemingly represents? The very fact that every member who wants to achieve an executive position in the CU has to sign this creed gives an almost exclusivist tone, appearing to force a set of beliefs on students as the ‘true’ Christianity.
These are just a few examples of what I see to be a negative impression put forward by the otherwise admirable CU. It is also not the Christianity that I know. Yes, Jesus said in Matthew 28:18-20 to “go and make disciples of all nations”, but nothing is said about how to do this. As our very own Bishop Butler stated in a recent sermon, it “does not work to force religion down people’s throats”. Surely then, it would make much more sense to present Christianity positively.
For me, Christianity isn’t scary, and I’m not in constant fear of God. I see it as a relationship with someone who loves me, and no healthy relationship starts out in fear. Since becoming a Christian, my life has changed, and, on the whole, I’m much happier. You could say this is a coincidence, yes, and that’s perfectly fine. It’s your opinion and I’m not here to argue. As Luther famously wrote, we are justified by our faith, and not our works—I try and live the life of a good Christian, and if people want to approach me about it then that’s great.
It seems more fitting now more than ever, at Christmas, that this idea of love and inclusion should be presented. The Bible shows Jesus as coming into this world to save us not to scare us, to include and not to exclude. Surely this is would be a far more beneficial image for DICCU to put across?
Photograph by Oliver Lansdowne via Creative Commons
