Sugar daddies: a positive alternative to student loans?

By Zoë Boothby

Seeking Arrangements, the world’s most popular ‘Sugar Daddies’ website, apparently now has 250,000 UK students as members. This 40 per cent hike in predominately young women signing up as ‘sugar babies’ has been attributed to the tripling of tuition fees from 2011. Many have asked the question of whether or not becoming a sugar baby is an acceptable way to fund oneself through higher education. Yet, when people have been paid upwards of £200 to go for a drink with someone, it is easy to see why this lifestyle attracts so many. If an individual is willing to offer such a sum for a platonic activity, and someone is tempted, why should they not be at liberty to accept?

The sugar daddies phenomenon is nothing new, but technology has only helped to facilitate the craze: it has now never been easier to find that someone special (read: rich) to accommodate for that jet-set lifestyle you crave. Yet, it is not just girls getting in on the action; the increase in successful, independent middle-aged women has meant that Sugar Mummies have also been on the rise. As usual, however, the media’s judgment of sugar babies is more often aimed at young women than men, and any moral analysis of the implications of such relationships look almost exclusively at sugar daddies and their partners.

Of course, these websites should absolutely not be a substitute for adequate student finance. No student should be forced to become financially dependent on one of these sites. Should this be the case, this would only serve to highlight the failure of the state to support its young people. Yet, it seems unlikely that there is any definitive correlation between economic insecurity and association with the sugar daddy world: the UK universities with the highest participation in such dating apps include Cambridge, Bristol and St. Andrews, whose student populations are amongst the most privileged in the country. Seeking Arrangements have reported that 56% of its sugar babies come from middle and upper-class families. This is perhaps more of an issue in the United States, where Seeking Arrangements have created spin-off projects such as ‘Sugar Baby University’, which encourages Sugar Daddies to act as ‘benefactors’ and aid in tuition payments. However, the exchanges are more often luxurious than functional, where sugar babies are gifted designer clothes, visits to fancy restaurants or five-star holidays . Whilst there are certainly patriarchal dimensions to an older man gifting a young woman a ‘weekly allowance’, it is at the discretion of the woman to decide to accept such payments as a means of supporting herself.

There are many who would call these exchanges prostitution, but it seems important to maintain the distinction: these relationships are not necessarily sexual, and the nature of such can be any number of things. The young women who sign up for these websites are completely upfront about sex, and state on their profiles if they are unwilling to engage in sexual activities. There are plenty of men who do not explicitly want physical intimacy, and are more interested in companionship: many sugar babies have been asked to simply keep a recent divorcee or widower company.

There are several safety issues which arise when considering any website of this kind, and it needs to be ensured that they are regulated and entirely safe for use. Because of the nature of the sites, I do think that companies should be making more of a concerted effort to monitor online activity and conversations to ensure that no sugar baby is coerced into anything they don’t want to do. The websites do advise users on safety issues, and encourage them to report any inappropriate behavior, but, as with all forms of social media, this could be done more emphatically.

Ultimately, this is an issue of choice: a lot of people who oppose the online sugar daddy trend seem to neglect the fact that it is the young women themselves who choose to sign up. Permitting that the website promotes safe and consensual arrangements between people, and as long as the sugar baby dictates the terms of the relationship, why should there be any issue? It does seem an attractive alternative to student loans.

Photograph: Jason Howie via creative commons