Essena O’Neill and the role of social media in our own lives

By Zoë Boothby
A couple of weeks back Essena O’Neill, an 18-year-old social media ‘star’, whose decision to quit the practice was, ironically, shared on Facebook and Twitter the world over, released an emotional video explaining her decision. She cited the impact of becoming too involved with an online world and letting herself “be defined by numbers” on her self-esteem. She deleted 2,000 photos off her Instagram and recaptioned the remaining ones, explaining the ‘true’ stories behind the pictures, describing hours-long photoshoots to capture the perfect shot and the times she starved herself to take the perfect ‘bikini pic’. The reaction to O’Neill’s statement, which some have classed as a ‘modern breakdown’, has been extremely mixed.
Many people have criticised Essena for not only her video but also her decision to quit social media by not really quitting social media. That the video is somewhat patronising cannot be denied: as someone who is often spotted sporting the ‘boho chic’ look (not showered in two days and not done a wash in two weeks) and rarely gets over 10 ‘likes’ on a profile picture (thanks friends), it could be quite difficult for me to generate sympathy for a model who complains about ‘having it all’ with her jet-set, #eatclean lifestyle. Yet, in this, O’Neill illustrates the issue perfectly: how skewed our modern definition of ‘having it all’ is. Is our generation’s idea of success really having 500,000 followers on social media? Not to everyone, definitely, but to a good number this is certainly true.
Kate Winslet has recently remarked that one of the impacts of social media is that is causes young people to “design themselves for people to like them.” I, for one, and I’m sure many others, can relate to this statement: in a world where our online presence is so pervasive and covers so many facets of our lives, from the personal to the professional, our online world is all about creating the most appealing versions of ourselves. It is becoming increasingly difficult for young people to be their ‘authentic self’ (another Insta-ism), when they feel hundreds of eyes burning through the computer screen.
Others have pointed out that Essena has actually just switched her preferred social media platform, swapping YouTube for Vimeo and Instagram for Tumblr. She has also been asking her followers to donate money to her as she can no longer afford to pay her rent. Although I can understand people’s discomfort with a former model and Instagram ‘guru’ asking her young followers for money, I also acknowledge the fact that what she is doing now is far more important. O’Neill is attempting to prompt a discussion about the role of social media in our lives, and, crucially, she is reaching out and trying to converse with some of the young followers who are probably also struggling with their own issues of self-confidence and likeability.
Essena’s message is not for everyone. I’ve seen so many statuses and blog posts stating that the only problem was Essena herself; that she was just vulnerable to the harmful effects of social media because of who she was as a person. Many people’s justification for this has been along the lines of, ‘Well, I’m fine. Social media has had no negative effect on me.’ Fair enough. If you do not want to listen, switch off. But it is for those who can’t switch off, for those whose self-esteem has suffered looking at pictures of their friends having fun without them, or those who have sat cradling their iPhone, patiently waiting for the ‘likes’ to add up. This, sadly, is a reality for many of our young people today, where social media has been a constant dimension in their adolescent lives.
I myself have a love-hate relationship with what seems like the ubiquitous online world of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, and similar platforms. I would be lying if I said my self-esteem had never been affected by social media. How many hours of my life have been frittered away obtaining masses of useless information about everyone and yet no-one in particular. In the course of writing this article, I deleted my Instagram. Not for any particular reason, I just couldn’t really be bothered anymore. Yet it felt good to recover that little bit of control over my life. Now I am a slave to one less little app on my phone, which can surely only be a step in the right direction.
Photograph: Phil Campbell via Flickr
