Spring budget 2023: the rich get richer?

By Grace Sargent

The Conservatives aimed to demonstrate their priorities in this Budget – stability and growth. However, despite their efforts, only 6% of Britons believe they will positively benefit as many argue this budget aids the wealthy more than working people. 

The Chancellor’s plan is targeted towards three of the Prime Minister’s priorities: halving inflation, economic growth and decreasing debt. Hunt’s slogan of the four E’s (enterprise, education, employment, everywhere) confirms the continuing Tory ‘levelling up’ agenda. 

The headline policy was Hunt’s pension plan as he abolished the lifetime pension allowance, raised the yearly tax-free pension threshold, and aiming to increase the workforce by 60,000. However, the reaction to this expensive policy (costing £800mn) was overwhelmingly negative as despite Hunt’s attempt to retain senior doctors, it enables the well-off to further increase their wealth. The significant focus on employment aims to increase the available workforce through policies such as Hunt’s pension benefits (especially to senior doctors) and increasing required work hours to claim Universal Credit. 

Despite criticism this budget benefits the wealthy, the Chancellor is providing £3,300 of support per family. Many policies appear popular with the public such as retaining the energy price guarantee (freezing the average household energy bill at £2,500 until June), the continued fuel duty freeze and the expansion of free childcare hours. Furthermore, the normalcy of policies regarding draft relief on beer, potholes, and aid to leisure centres further exhibits the Tories’ mission – stability. Particularly after Kwarteng’s calamitous budget and three of the previous five Chancellors not lasting long enough to produce their own. However, Hunt’s self-described ‘budget for growth’ after thirteen Tory years became the foundation of the Opposition’s argument that this period has been the “managed decline” of Britain. 

Hunt did not address strikes in his speech, possibly trying to appeal to those disengaged with the widespread disruption.

There was also continuity, with department budgets widely maintained except for increasing support for Ukraine by $11bn – a policy with widespread support. This continuity demonstrates the current economic restraints and denounces significant public sector pay rises (despite a believed Junior Doctor pay settlement pending). Hunt did not address strikes in his speech, possibly trying to appeal to those disengaged with the widespread disruption. Furthermore, many policies are targeted beyond the next General Election, with the free thirty hours of weekly childcare not implemented until 2025 – an incentive to vote Tory at the next election or the Conservatives creating policies they will not have to fulfil? 

With wide-ranging policies from further levelling-up through twelve new investment zones to pledging £20bn towards low-carbon energy, Hunt wants to create his enterprise economy in a landscape of public-sector breakdown and struggling families. However, policies of corporation tax increases and relief to those on pre-payment metres show the Conservative’s aim to be portrayed as the party of ‘ordinary people’ to retain their Red Wall support. The Labour party, wanting to regain their old heartlands, denounced the Chancellor’s plan and affirm the country remains needing ‘major surgery’ economically, which the Opposition argues only they can deliver. 

The Conservatives appear duller and more technocratic under Sunak (versus Johnson), but they retain many core principles, especially expressing Brexit’s advantages and the continuation of ‘Levelling Up.’ Hunt’s ‘Brexit pubs guarantee’ (the increase of draft relief) may evidence a simple but effective way of proving Brexit’s advantages in a political climate of wider issues such as instability in Northern Ireland. 

The Welsh Government characterised this budget as a ‘sticking plaster approach to the economy’ and denounced the lack of funding towards health, social services, and local government. Perhaps the public agrees with only 1 in 5 believing this was a good budget. Hunt would argue he has optimised the positives in a challenging economic climate.  

However, Labour has retained their 15-point lead, despite positive headlines such as no technical recession this year, perhaps stemming from continuing declines in disposable income and employment instability which policies based on enterprise are distant from. 

The plea for political stability, both from the public and the imploding Conservative Party, may have been answered by a re-establishing of order. The Spring Budget demonstrates how the Tories desire to be perceived at the next election: as the party of both enterprise and working people. The question is: can you be both simultaneously? 

Image: HM Treasury via Flickr