Can America change?
Content Warning: this article contains discussion of gun violence.
By Grace Sargent
Uvalde, Buffalo, Parkland, Sandy Hook, Nashville – five mass shootings, five disasters, one weapon of choice – the AR-15. The US has approximately 25 million AR-15s in circulation – it is impossible America’s guns can ever be ‘controlled’?
The Second Amendment guarantees Americans the right to bear arms. However, the right is controversial and arguably outdated. For example, the complexity and abilities of guns in 1791 (when the amendment was ratified) are incomparable to modern firearms. It was believed weapons were required to protect citizens rights and the democratic state, with many arguing for its continuation.
Gun control in America is inherently political
Revising the Amendment requires political consensus, which is impossible in a partisan senate. Instead, the solution proposed by moderates are “gun control measures” ranging from background checks to banning certain models. Whether solutions can solve a problem this widespread is contestable versus the power of a federal assault weapon ban. Proponents of gun control argue stricter regulations must be implemented to reduce gun-related violence; however, opposers argue these violate constitutional rights. President Biden recently called himself a ‘second amendment guy’ but acknowledged this right is not absolute which was also recognised by the Supreme Court. Therefore, gun control can be legislated without violating the Second Amendment if restrictions are deemed reasonable and not infringing on the rights of ownership for law-abiding citizens. Consequently, a federal level intervention cannot occur.
Gun control in America is inherently political. Bewilderingly, Republican Congressmen have continued to wear AR-15 lapel pins, despite the weapon continually claiming numerous lives. Moreover, it appears behaviours will not change exhibited by Representative Ogles’s defence of his gun-toting Christmas card doubling-down on his families right to bear arms. The President himself declared his personal shotgun ownership, a senseless decision from the ‘Leader of the Free World’ in a supposedly comforting speech in a time of national anguish. The affirmation of his desire to maintain the second amendment immediately after Nashville, and subsequent disasters, is nonsensical to many, especially Democrats.
Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez continued to challenge the pro-gun narrative stating on Twitter she would offer Representative McCarthy [the Speaker of the House] ‘a spine in exchange for some gun safety legislation.’ Democrats like AOC are fighting against the multi-million-dollar gun lobby which supports the Republican Party, a divided senate, and surprisingly conservative centrist Democrats. The polarising nature of American politics demonstrates why consensus, and subsequent action, appears impossible.
To many outside America, countless events taking numerous lives with the same weapon is incomprehensible. More unfathomable is how this only inspires ‘thoughts and prayers’, not action. The Dunblane Massacre of 1996 remains in living-memory for many Britons. The attack at the Scottish primary school mirrors school shootings across the pond yet provoked a completely different result. When writing to Parkland survivors, Dunblane students described how ‘laws were changed, handguns were banned and the level of gun violence in Britain is now one of the lowest in the world.’ A single tragedy caused major change, yet in America hundreds of shootings have occurred since Parkland. The fundamental importance of the second amendment is incomprehensible to Britons but remains ingrained in America’s national fabric. Hypothetically the reversal of one amendment could create a precedent. What other “fundamental” rights could disappear? – legal rights, freedoms, the vote? Undoubtedly, British governmental revisions regarding private gun ownership worked with the UK having five guns for every 100 people, compared to 120 in the US. It is a gamble America should take.
The sanctity of the Second Amendment is divisive – there is no middle ground
It seems simple, the country with the highest per capita gun ownership has the most gun crime – more guns equals more death. Overall, America’s political system favours state level restrictions instead of federal paternalism, for example, after Sandy Hook Connecticut and New York passed stricter gun laws – an expected reaction. On April 4th three Democratic Tennessee lawmakers advocated for gun control in the House of Representatives. The response by Tennessee’s Republican Representatives was to remove them for ‘disorder and dishonour’ with accusations of attempting to incite an insurrection. How can there be no federal consensus in the face of so many tragedies?
The sanctity of the Second Amendment is divisive – there is no middle ground. Whilst Democrats argue for stricter gun laws, Republicans advocate for their guns believing it equals less crime. However, outside of politics many Americans are exhausted and astonished at the unrelenting continuity. As a woman asked the news broadcasters in Nashville, ‘aren’t you guys tired of being here and having to cover all of these mass shootings?’ The ubiquitous gun violence epidemic continues after Nashville, just as it did before. However, from outsiders and a growing (albeit sometimes quiet) majority there is a belief something must change, but it is doubtful anything meaningful.
Image: UraniumRailroad via Flickr
