Are the riots in France truly effective?
By Grace Sargent
The shooting of 17-year-old Nahel Merzouk in Nanterre, a suburb of Paris, triggered enormous uproar throughout France. Despite the large scale violence it appears there is little desire for change from institutions, therefore, does rioting really achieve anything?
On the 23rd of June Nahel Merzouk was shot by police in Nanterre after a police chase. The 17-year-old was of Algerian descent leading to accusations of racial profiling and police brutality which instigated successive days of rioting. In the days following Merzouk’s death state institutions, from town halls to police stations, were attacked causing an estimated over a billion euros worth of damage and over seven hundred police officers injured.
The killing represents a wider debate surrounding the treatment of other ethnicities by law enforcement
Perhaps the reason for the extent of discontent is that Nahel’s story is not unique, it has even been showcased in critically acclaimed films such as ‘La Haine.’ The killing represents a wider debate surrounding the treatment of other ethnicities by law enforcement. Multiculturalism in France has been outwardly celebrated, for example the 1998 football team adopted the motto ‘black, blanc, beur’, to celebrate the diversity of the French population – including the Arabic ‘beurs.’ However, tensions remain alongside celebrations of diversity – especially for those in poorer areas.
The story of Nahel – an immigrant of North African descent from a single parent family – and his treatment from police is representative, especially for those from the banlieues. Moreover, this reaction from the public is not unique. For example, the widespread riots in 2005 were triggered by police brutality towards Muslim teenagers with dissatisfaction with the then-governments response and believed police brutality caused riots lasting three weeks. President Macron has deemed the police’s treatment of Nahel inexcusable but affirmed the protestors should be peaceful.
Therefore, the question is, ‘If nothing has changed from previous riots, do they really achieve anything?’ Very little has changed regarding police brutality or social conditions in Paris’s banlieues. However, are riots supposed to achieve an end goal? On the contrary, they are a method of expressing discontent, especially when no other method of demonstrating dissatisfaction is possible. Other methods, such as petitions and high court cases, have also been unsuccessful in instrumenting change. Therefore, what is the solution?
The rioters are profoundly young with the average age of those arrested seventeen. Macron implored parents to discipline their children and affirmed the influence of social media on teenagers – the video of Merzouk’s killing has circulated widely online. For many young people they have trust in their institutions or belief that their life will improve. The President’s belief social media glamourizes conflict and violence in cities led to his threat to cut off the platforms – an authoritarian measure that doesn’t tackle the root issue of these riots.
Riots may be ineffective but how else can people show their discontent to a system that remains unchanged?
Other officals, such as the mayor of Chanteloup-les-Vignes, have recognised the root cause of the riots – poor living conditions – which have worsened since the 2005 riots. Many deem Nanterre, Nahel’s home suburb, the exile for France’s neglected and unwanted. Moreover, those of Algerian descent have been subjected to police violence since they entered France in the 1960 – for example, they are more likely to be stopped and subjected to violence by police.
Riots may be ineffective but how else can people show their discontent to a system that remains unchanged? To many rioting is a “typically French” reaction, however, this shooting has triggered unparalleled unrest to the last twenty years. These riots are not necessarily an example to uphold worldwide. However, when all methods of voicing discontent – such as protests as over 6000 people marched in support of Merzouk’s family in Nanterre – are ineffective which is best to utilise.
Rioting and violence is a way frustrated people express their opinion when left with no resort. It achieves very little. However, the French public (especially those from low socio-economic areas) have seen many areas of their life regress rather than improve leading to increased frustration. Nahel’s story is representative of the issues many face.
To many the anger is understandable, the violence and looting is not. However, Nahel’s death represents to many the unfair treatment of minorities in France, especially by institutions. Whilst some may argue these riots have occurred due to criminals profiteering over discontent, these riots are the consequence of deep disillusionment and worsening living conditions. Moreover, these are not new feelings or issues. For many from Nahel’s background these issues have been long acknowledged by authorities, there simply is no desire to aid them.
Image credit: HubertdeThé via Pixabay
