Spare the rod, spoil the Orang-utan: it was right to sack Clarkson
Avid fans of mine may recall my first Palatinate article on Top Gear’s Falklands controversy, in which I spoke up for the motoring programme’s presenters’ rights as entertainers in a free world. How apt it is that Jeremy Clarkson the show’s chief Orang-utan has given me fodder for what will probably be my last article this academic year.
On 25 March 2015, BBC Director General Lord Hall announced that Clarkson’s contract with the BBC would not be renewed following an ‘unprovoked physical attack’ on producer Oisin Tymon over a lack of hot food in the hotel where the presenters were staying. Although Lord Hall claimed to be a fan of Clarkson’s work and Top Gear in particular, the sacking was an ‘unavoidable’ decision. Unavoidable indeed – there can be no excuse for Clarkson’s actions, particularly not the claim that he was allegedly drunk. Jeremy Clarkson had as much right in doing what he did as you would if you punched the dinner lady on arriving at the servery the morning after a Klute Tuesday to find that the scrambled eggs had run out. Free you may be to moan about the unique way in which the servery is funded – I would, in fact, encourage you to do so. That’s your right to freedom of speech. And the people behind you in line would have the right to disagree or tell you to shut up, but provided they did not react violently to what you say, you have no right to turn around and punch them – hungover or not.
The economic and cultural impacts of Clarkson’s sacking are immense. The BBC claim that Top Gear will continue in the same way that The Beatles could have continued without John Lennon, but it will simply never be the same. How much viewership will be affected remains to be seen. James May and Richard Hammonds’ contracts are also at stake James May has explicitly stated that the trio are a package. Despite this potentially messy chain of events, sparing the rod this time would really spoil the Orang-utan.
Despite choosing to write for a newspaper designed for the intellectually unstimulated, Piers Morgan raises some very valid points in his letter to Clarkson. Clarkson must resist the ‘temptation to slag off (his) former bosses’. In all likelihood, Clarkson will be less outspoken without his nanny the BBC, but, as Morgan correctly points out, Clarkson is going through a highly stressful period. On top of his sacking, he has several health issues and a broken marriage to negotiate. Nonetheless, it is highly unlikely that this will be the end of Clarkson’s media career. With a cult-like following in many parts of the world, he is sure to be inundated with offers in due time. As Morgan suggests, now would be an ideal time for Clarkson to go on a low-key holiday and do some timely reflection.
The medicine is harsh but the patient requires it in order to live. Jeremy, you know you have crossed the line when I quote two people I generally disagree with in the same article. I love you and Top Gear:I spent my teenage years thinking about you more than any female celebrity half your age. No seriously I did. But for the sake of your ego, I can no longer afford to defend your whim to say and do as you please. That is simply not your right.
Photograph: Tony Harrison

