Countering radicalisation at university: not too little but too late
By GK Teh
Last September, the government introduced legislation making it compulsory for universities to train their staff to identify impressionable students and colleagues at risk of falling under the spell of the far right. By law, Student Unions also have to comply with strict protocol when inviting extremist speakers to universities and ensuring that they do not speak unopposed. Credit where credit is due – Jo Johnson’s legislature is largely sensible. There may, perhaps, be grounds to argue that these policies do not adequately tackle such illiberal values as sexism and racially-motivated bullying at universities, but I would be reluctant to believe so without evidence in due course.
However, it is unfair to place such immense responsibility on universities. The people most vulnerable to influence by extremist thought are those who have been discriminated against by the community in which they live in. Discrimination on grounds of religion, race, gender, appearance and hair colour (to name a few) are institutionalised beliefs. And people, of course, are exposed to these institutions literally as soon as they enter this world. Babies are more likely to choose playmates who resemble them. This is an attitude that will develop through every institution you can send your child to. Nursery, school, college, sports teams, drama companies, the Scouts – the list is endless.
The government is not entirely blind to the pressing need to start countering radicalisation from an early age. In July, the Prime Minister announced a new counter-extremism strategy, starting with the Prevent anti-extremist watch duty scheme, making it compulsory for schools to report any sudden mid-year dropouts and sustained absences so Border Control can evaluate whether to seize their passports. However there is so much more that can be done. The government should look towards donations towards youth institutions such as the Muslim Scout Fellowship to encourage more participation in this branch of a fantastic organisation.
Let us not neglect discussing radicalisation in the context of neo-Nazism. Similar policies should be applied. I believe a General Education course in society and politics should be implemented in Local Educational Authority (State) primary and secondary schools, available up to GCSE level. Only through such programmes can the dangers of the far right and left be instilled in youths. Organisations such as Quilliam and the Liberal Club should play a bigger role in establishing politically liberal – particularly Liberal Democrat – societies at universities. Stressing the importance of liberalism and the centre ground is of utmost importance in dealing with religious and political extremism.
However, these are rather simplistic views. Perhaps I have jumped too quickly onto the bandwagon opinion that the government should play the biggest role in laying out counter-extremist policy. Could it be beneficial to exercise more laissez-faire? I am unfortunately unconvinced that providing more training for every university is an effective use of resources. On the contrary, training in institutions where the relationship between all faiths and ethnicities has been erstwhile harmonious could amount to divisiveness. Certainly, several highly-trained teams of counter-extremist experts should be provided, but only deployed if the administrators of a university sees fit. When not engaged with universities, they should be working with schools, mosques and community centres.
I commend the Universities taking a larger role in tackling extremism. Freedom of speech is both a right and a responsibility – the latter component is sadly forgotten on occasion. However, focusing on universities solely is insufficient. While the fundamental premises of free speech, and exchanging ideas, at Universities make it more conducive and easily blameable for the radicalisation of youths, such processes are typically the long-term result of subjecting an individual to practices which stunt their equality of opportunity in their community, which should be a safe space.
Photograph: Durham University
