Greek austerity: Syriza knows best

By G K Teh

The views expressed in this article are those of the author and not necessarily of Palatinate.

 

Over 60% of Germans today believe that Germany is no longer truly democratic. A recent poll highlighted that over 60% of Germans polled believe that German politics is wandering too far towards the right. The Conservative leash is becoming increasingly apparent with Finance Minister Wolfgang Schauble’s near-autocratic control on Syriza’s economic policies. Europe is not meant to be run like a business.

Austerity has never had much success in reducing debt in any European country – particularly Greece. That Greek unemployment rates have rocketed from 11.7% to 25.9% between March 2010 (the month after the implementation of the first austerity package) and August 2014 is no coincidence. That this rate peaked at an average of 27.9% between September and October 2013 (in the aftermath of the last austerity package) is even less coincidental.

The basic premise behind the seven austerity packages thus far is that the medicine is harsh, but necessary for the patient to live. But the patient would benefit very much from a second opinion. Austerity is causing rapid organ failure. The diminished healthcare allowance has caused a 50% increase in the prevalence of HIV-AIDS and similar increases in other STD’s. Other social indicators only further define the dire situation. With a 40% increase in suicide rates and a GDP decline of 6.9% in 2011, Merkel’s only remaining responsible option is to admit that her austerity packages do Greece more harm than good.

The argument against austerity is furthered given the risk of Greece leaving the Eurozone. Without the EU’s assistance, Greece would not be able to pay its dues in bailout loans to the EU. Countries would have to put the responsibility of picking up the 215 billion Euro tab on European taxpayers – potentially causing serious unrest in Spain and other countries already plagued by economic troubles.

Is there any room for austerity in Greece at all? Perhaps, albeit with a much stronger economy. The Grexit would be ruinous for Greece, the EU, and, ultimately, the UK. But Merkel’s iron fist policies will crush Greece – not guide it to salvation – if allowed to continue uninterrupted. Panic-driven spending boosts are just as bad as panic-driven austerity. But Finance Minister Yanis Varoufaki’s plans to suspend debt payments, increase public spending, create 300,000 jobs, a 29.4% increase in the minimum wage, and a 75% income tax on incomes above 500,000 Euros show that despite its ‘radical left’ branding, it understands very well that a country needs to earn money to save money; that a country needs to earn money to make repayments. Only after GDP growth should the EU’s Thatcher-wannabes apply some of the efficiency measures in their austerity packages (such as raising the retirement age).

Despite Tsipras’ Communist backgrounds, it is clear that Syriza understands what is best for Greece. The country needs to spend money to earn money. Only with some surplus should the implementation of efficiency measures be considered.

If you would like to express a different view to that of this author, please email in a contribution to politics@palatinate.org.uk

 

Photograph: Wikipedia

Alexis Tsiparis