Southampton batter woeful Black Cats
By Will Fremont-Barnes
Until this weekend, Sunderland’s underwhelming start to the season had gone under the radar as attention focused on Newcastle United, their crisis-hit local rivals. Yet there is no hiding place anymore after a humiliating 8-0 defeat at St Mary’s left them looking every bit as vulnerable as they were for the majority of last year.
Southampton made them look an absolute shambles, slicing through Sunderland’s defence with embarrassing ease. Dusan Tadic and Graziano Pelle, stars of this superb team performance, prove that there is still value in the transfer market having arrived from Dutch football this summer for a combined total of around £20 million. Their opponents had roughly the same amount of talent sitting on the bench in the form of Adam Johnson and Jack Rodwell, both of whom were massively overpriced because of the premium on English players.
The problem on Saturday was not, however, that Sunderland have consistently spent money poorly throughout owner Ellis Short’s tenure at the club, but that they cannot defend to save their lives. They are fortunate that their next scheduled meeting with Southampton, a team that will win plenty of games and admirers over the course of the season, is not until the beginning of May, although the prospect of Arsenal, Everton, Chelsea and Manchester City coming to the Stadium of Light in the coming weeks is a terrifying one based on Saturday’s evidence.

Santiago Vergini’s comical own-goal, a quite remarkable feat of horrendous defending, in the 12th minute put Sunderland on the back foot from the beginning. He got what looked to be an attempted clearance horribly wrong, slicing an effort beyond Vito Mannone, who wore a disbelieving look shared by pretty much everyone else inside the ground. Yet even then there was little to suggest that Sunderland would capitulate in the pathetic manner that they did, nor when they retreated into the dressing-room 3-0 down at half-time following Pelle’s tap-in and Jack Cork’s bundled effort from close-range.
From there things only got worse as Southampton emerged for the second-half with the same purpose and intensity as they had begun the first, urged forward by their determined manager. An avid tweeter, Ronald Koeman had predicted a difficult afternoon against ‘strong opponents with a good defence and organisation’ prior to kick-off. What unfolded before him made that tweet appear wildly inaccurate as Sunderland continued to defend with all the lethargy and haphazardness of a poor Sunday league team.
Liam Bridcutt got his feet in a horrible tangle as the score reached four; Pelle slotted home from a tight angle to make it five; Tadic looped the ball into an unguarded net following Mannone’s wayward clearance for six; substitute Victor Wanyama lashed home a seventh; and finally, Saido Mane scored his first league goal – Southampton’s eighth, making up for a missed chance in the previous fixture against Tottenham, and securing the most comprehensive Premier League win for nearly two years and Southampton’s biggest margin of victory since 1921.
Describing the whole affair as his “most embarrassing” in football, Gus Poyet revealed afterwards that he had learnt a lot about some of his players on a day that Sunderland lacked character rather than quality. The catalogue of errors leading up to several of the goals was indicative of a team that had long given up trying, uninterested in trying to keep the scoreline respectable. Lee Cattermole, tipped by some for an England call-up in the wake of Fabien Delph and Jonjo Shelvey’s inclusions, was a passenger for much of the second-half, playing in central midfield without the edge that has earned him praise.
You also have to wonder how much Poyet learnt about himself. Some of his selection decisions were strange to say the least, most notably the inclusion of Connor Wickham as a left-hand sided attacking player. It was clear right from the beginning that Southampton’s Nathaniel Clyne would have a field day in an attacking sense, able to advance a significant length without meeting any resistance. No wonder Southampton enjoyed so much success down the right flank.
Poyet, now exactly a year into the job, has had a fairly easy ride from the media and supporters since taking over. The dire situation he inherited, and the heroic Capital One Cup run, bought him some time, as did the dramatic nature of their Premier League survival. However, with the club hovering perilously above the relegation zone off the back of their worst defeat in 32 years, it is legitimate to question the progress Sunderland have made under Poyet. With arguably a weaker team than that which narrowly avoided relegation in May, there is no reason to think they face anything other than a scrap for 17th place this time around.
Poyet began his managerial career with a 3-1 win at St Mary’s with Brighton in a League One fixture. A lot has changed in the five years since. Southampton have gone from strength to strength, establishing themselves as the most complete team outside the nailed-on top seven, whilst the Uruguayan is in charge of a side destined for an arduous campaign. With Sunderland looking to hang onto their Premier League status, another resounding defeat would leave Poyet hanging onto his job.
Photograph: wikipedia
