Clinical Manchester United overcome struggling Liverpool
By Will Fremont-Barnes
What a difference nine months makes. When this fixture was played back in March, Liverpool were totally dominant, Manchester United totally out of sorts. The roles, like the scoreline from that day, have been reversed completely, with United exacting revenge by virtue of a 3-0 victory that leaves Brendan Rodgers skating on thin ice this Christmas time, as David Moyes was when Liverpool ran riot at Old Trafford last season.
This is a fixture that matters on both sides of the divide. As United fans celebrated their team’s most memorable result and performance since Alex Ferguson retired, they also chanted with glee about Rodgers’ misfortune and Steven Gerrard’s tendency to slip on crucial occasions. Gerrard, unlike many of his peers on a weekend of yet more diving controversies, managed to stay on his feet, but hardly had a sniff against a United midfield marshalled superbly by Wayne Rooney. Rodgers did nothing to lift the mounting pressure from his shoulders. His owners cannot be happy about Liverpool’s unacceptably sudden decline. Kenny Dalglish, now a director at the club, did a poor job of disguising his emotions.
Liverpool’s critics have spent too long making simple observations about the damage done by Luis Suarez’s departure. His goals and impact on the team are impossible to replace, yet whilst his absence was notable yesterday, as it has been all season, the centre-forward role is not the only area of the team in which Liverpool are deficient. David de Gea’s magnificent performance in goal highlighted Liverpool’s weakness in that particular area, with the error-prone Simon Mignolet dropped ahead of this crucial game. Having backed him all the way up until now, this was a strange time to lose faith in the Belgian and hand understudy Brad Jones his first league start in nearly two years.

It proved a poor selection decision on Rodgers’ part. After de Gea made the first of a number of crucial saves to deny Raheem Sterling in the 11th minute, United went straight up the other end to take the lead. Luis Antonio Valencia skipped past Joe Allen far too easily on the right touchline, and the wing-back pulled a clever ball back as everyone was waiting for a cross to come into the six-yard box. Everyone was waiting, that is, except Rooney, who timed his run from deep perfectly to meet the ball and steer United in front. Jones’s attempt to save the shot, however, was poor. Instead of standing up and waiting to find out the direction of Rooney’s effort, the promoted keeper dived early in anticipation, and was consequently made to look rather silly as the ball sailed past him in the opposite corner.
Liverpool reversion to three at the back, copying United’s makeshift system, was also a surprise. They were rocked by an early injury to Glen Johnson, one of their best performers in an otherwise underperforming team, and Kolo Toure’s introduction did nothing to deter United from piling on the pressure. Louis van Gaal’s admirable faith in youth saw young James Wilson handed a start ahead of Radamel Falcao, and he gave Liverpool’s back three plenty to think about with his pace and energy, not to mention with his clever link-up play with Robin van Persie.
Inadvertently, the Dutchman had a big part to play in United’s second goal. He got a flick on a cross into the box, the slightest of connections that should have ruled Juan Mata offside. The linesman, like most people in the ground, including the Liverpool players, failed to spot this, and so did not raise his flag when Mata nodded home from close range.
Liverpool had spent the first-half playing without a striker. Sterling was the most advanced player wearing yellow, performing the role of a false No. 9 without a great deal of success. Every time Liverpool broke on the counter-attack, they did so with too much enthusiasm, consistently misplacing their passes as a result. With Mario Balotelli’s arrival on the scene, at Adam Lallana’s expense, Liverpool should have been more direct after the break.
They did improve after half-time, creating a fair number of opportunities to get back in the game. Sterling seemed certain to score when Jonny Evans miscued his back-pass, but he dithered whilst trying to get around de Gea, and the Spaniard blocked the ensuing attempt on goal. Then Sterling combined with Balotelli, who could count himself extremely unfortunate not to have opened his account for Liverpool in the Premier League when his shot was tipped onto the bar by a brilliant flying save by de Gea.
This simply was not Liverpool’s day. United poured forward again in search of more goals, getting their reward when Rooney’s under-hit pass was cleared unsuccessfully by Dejan Lovren and fell kindly to Mata. Instead of shooting from edge of the area, which would have been thoroughly tempting at that stage of the game, Mata kept his composure and laid the ball off to van Persie for a tap-in. Jones had no chance this time.
De Gea still had time to secure his man of the match award. Liverpool seemed set to grab a consolation goal when Balotelli was put clean through on goal, but again United’s unbeatable keeper showed himself to be just that. He was fantastic on a day when the scoreline would have been a lot less flattering in United’s favour without his help. As it was, the result was so clear cut that van Gaal was able to bring Paddy McNair on for the final few minutes as a way of easing him back into the first team after a rough ride at St Mary’s on Monday night.
Although United’s defence still requires some serious work on the training ground, its weaknesses are less apparent when Rooney and de Gea are in such sparkling form. Liverpool lack the centre-forward and goalkeeper to cover their inadequacies, and as such find themselves in a very similar position to the one United found themselves in nine months ago. There is plenty of goodwill towards Rodgers, just as there was then towards Moyes, but the Liverpool manager should view that comparison with a degree of trepidation, because affection from the supporters and owners will not be enough to save him if this slump continues.
Photograph: wikipedia
