Sitcom stigmitisation: the fuel behind fatphobia and bodyshaming

By Sophie Tice

Think of a character in any TV show or movie: preferably a woman, they must be fat; in a loving and sexually-satisfying relationship; and without any significant implicit or explicit wonder at the combination of these facts. Try it. The only people I can recall are half the characters in UK soaps such as ‘EastEnders’: demonised as dramatic and unrealistic trash, which appropriately corresponds to the percentage of fat, in-love and sexually-satisfied individuals I know in real life.

Strangely, however, such people seem mysteriously extinct in most of the TV shows those of our generation (and beyond) grew up watching. ‘Friends’, ‘How I Met Your Mother’ and every other show based around the ‘late 20s life in a big American city’ commercial goldmine seems to exist in a skinny-swept version of reality. They are filled with disproportionately white, very slim and conventionally attractive individuals yet, nevertheless, meant to somehow emit a sense of ‘relatability’ about the romantic, platonic and professional struggles of the age.

They are filled with disproportionately white, very slim and conventionally attractive individuals.

However, given the demographic abnormality of their characters, such relatability is a dangerous pretense. If only skinny, white and attractive people fill our screens, then it is natural to absorb the misconception that one has to exemplify these characteristics to lead the exciting, friend-filled and romantic life of these characters. Be skinny and attractive or be unhappy.

However, the problem goes further than a lack of representation. These shows promote blatant fatphobia and consistent body shaming. Think of the presentation of Monica in ‘Friends’. Monica used to be a ‘fat loser’ but transformed into a desirable skinny success, her former fatness used as a regular comic ‘gotcha’ by her friends; lazy writing to the extreme. There is one entire sequence with just ‘fat Monica’ dancing happily with a doughnut in hand, the laugh track sounding in derision at the hilarity that is a fat person moving and, of course, eating at all times, because fat people have no self-control. ‘Fat Monica’ is unhygienic, as opposed to her obsessively clean skinny counterpart, commonly found with some sweet powder or sauce smearing her face; love-lorn and undesirable, her unreadiness to have sex only existing in the alternate, fat universe because apparently fat people cannot feel confident or free in their sexuality; and even dangerous, Ross having dreams of being crushed by her mass.

‘Friends’ is 119 hours long, and most people have watched episodes repeatedly. That is over 119 hours of absorbing a blatantly fatphobic and body-shaming narrative of reality, informing young girls that weight loss is the only path to desirability and feminine power. It does not take a genius to work out that the unconscious absorption of such an unhealthy narrative contributes to the negative body image currently plaguing the globe and its association with the world’s most fatal mental illness, an eating disorder.

The 90s were a special time for skinniness and celebrity. ‘Heroin chic’ dominated the fashion world, characterised by extreme thinness, dark eye circles and models such as Kate Moss.

There is always a sense of surprise or often an entire plot around the mysterious idea that a fat woman may be considered attractive.

However, it is clear that such a one dimensional and often unhealthy vision of beauty and attractiveness is far from banished decades on. ‘How I Met Your Mother’ replicates the unrepresentativeness of ‘Friends’ while only being more direct with its fat-phobia. In one example, Barney pays for the gym memberships of fat women, doubly encapsulating the show’s worrying conception of sexual manipulation and consent: “I invest in women who – how can I put this delicately? – they FAT. I give them the attention they don’t get now, and when they get hot, who do they come to? The guy who gave them attention back when they weren’t.” Even in broadcasts which feature larger women, such as Rebel Wilson’s ‘Isn’t It Romantic’ or even ‘This is Us’, there is always a sense of surprise or often an entire plot around the mysterious idea that a fat woman may be considered attractive or be fallen in love with.

There has been much attention upon the potentially harmful effect of social media upon self-esteem and body image, and rightly so. However, we also need to appreciate that even those lazy, split-tab sessions of ‘Friends’ and essay writing have an impact upon our subconscious with a negative perception of all except the white, skinny and conventionally attractive body. This is not just harmless entertainment; it is a condensed reflection of a fatphobic society and back-hand contributor to poor mental health. I doubt many will take this as an impetus to avoid among the most beloved TV shows of all time. However, if our inescapably body-shaming world has had its toxic effect upon you, it is worth considering that taking the active choice to surround yourself with more positive environmental influences might just be worth it.

Photograph: Codyxia via Flickr