The link between eating disorders and veganism

By Sophie Tice

Content warning: this article discusses eating disorders which some readers may find upsetting.

When I first read The Times’ headline on this topic, I laughed. “Vegan food is off the menu at top private school Cheltenham Ladies College (CLC) : Pupils who follow diet given blood tests amid anorexia fears”, it crowed. Of course: yet another attempt to find a single, curable ‘thing’ culpable for the world’s deadliest mental health condition – let’s ignore families, genetics and the overwhelming body-shaming nature of our society for the blameable fads of youth.

On closer investigation, however, I found the headline was an unfortunate victim of overzealous enthusiasm for mediocre wordplay: vegan food was never on the menu at CLC. The only real change is that the school is now offering blood tests for those who chose to become vegan, its aim being to combat veganism’s association with, and indeed the existence of, eating disorders.

I’m a big fan. One of my closest friends, whilst at boarding school, underwent the dreaded and hateful process of compulsory weighing at the local school clinic. What could have transformed from anxiety-inducing to a shining opportunity for help failed when, noticing a significant drop in weight since her last check-in, the nurse accepted my friend’s excuse that she had “been wearing shoes last time”. Only months later, my friend entered a psychiatric hospital, days away from starvation.

She, like so many others, had become vegan in the development of her eating disorder. Indeed, in one study, the National Centre for Eating Disorders at Newbridge House found that it had four times as many vegans and double the number of vegetarian patients compared with the same national age group samples. Meanwhile, more than two-thirds of participants of a separate 2013 study agreed that there was a relationship between their vegetarianism and their eating disorder.

Turning vegan or vegetarian during the development of an eating disorder is commonplace.

This is not to claim that being vegan can lead to having an eating disorder. Rather, it is to suggest that turning vegan or vegetarian during the develop-ment of an eating disorder is commonplace and indeed can become part of the disorder itself. Orthorexia, the unhealthy obsession with so-called ‘clean eating’, is one contributor often seen in anorexia sufferers. First, the avoidance of certain foods – fat, gluten and often meat – is likely the result of the facts that nearly all anorexia-sufferers will know and probably forever recollect: there are four calories per gram of carbohydrate and nine per gram of fat. However, like much of the disorder, it develops into illogical anxiety that consumption of these foods will result in unrealistic weight-gain and a general lack of control.

Moreover, it is socially acceptable. If people see you slowly munching on lettuce every day and gradually growing thinner, they will eventually become suspicious. Veganism, however, becomes the best, unquestionable excuse. Its overwhelmingly positive ethical and environmental effect makes other young people in particular reluctant to question your stated motivation. Forgetting the now widespread availability of ‘vegan fun foods’ – delicious vegan meats, cheeses and ice creams – weight loss becomes an explainable effect of the myth of instant vegan healthiness that contributed towards its absorption into the eating disorder in the first place.

With this information in hand, I understand CLC’s reluctance to promote or even allow a vegan diet. Moreover, blood tests could compose a fantastic method of providing an early sign to the services, if they make sure to listen and follow up, that there is a problem on an individual and collective level. However, they must remember that veganism can be a symptom, not a cause, of an eating disorder. The College must make sure to do more to com-bat the breeding ground for eating disorders that the competitive, all-girls environment of the College and our body-shaming culture allows for, formulating a clear plan to promote body acceptance and easy availability of professional help.

Furthermore, they must make the step to introduce vegan op-tions into their menu. Avoiding this diet, as they have already seen, will hardly magically cure the problem of eating disorders. Instead, it will feed unhealthy self-explanation and justify public excuses for why those with eating disorders are not eating, delaying help and external rec-ognition until the situation has become dire. There is no easy fix for eating disorders, but, like any mental health condition, collaboration and understanding is certainly a better option than fear.

Photograph: Vegan Liftz via Unsplash