Should clubs compromise their identities?

By Horatio Holloway

In 2016, Leicester City, a cellar-dweller side who’d avoided relegation the season prior in what was at the time considered other-worldly circumstances, won the Premier League. They were the favourite for relegation at the start of the campaign, condemned to the very pits of the dregs, the surest bet any bookmaker had to NOT lay a fingertip on the title. And they won. They’d never won before. They probably never will again. And the name of every player who’d set foot upon a teamsheet that season is permanently seared into the minds of every Fox and football superfan forevermore. Kasper Schmeichel. Wes Morgan. N’Golo Kante. Riyad Mahrez. Jamie Vardy. Enshrined in the cast of Leicestershire heroes, to stay.

Now imagine an alternate scenario. Leicester, in the Summer of 2015, are purchased by Elon Musk. Jose Mourinho is appointed manager instead of the out-of-luck Claudio Ranieri. Vardy is sold to Blackburn, and Kante to Saint-Etienne or something, replaced by Sergio Aguero and Eden Hazard earning a million-a-week each: the joint-second highest earners behind Cristiano Ronaldo, who Jose has riding the bench. All of them will be gone by 2017. Leicester achieve the exact same record, and win the league. Their fans rejoice. Local tescos still make hefty profit on their champagne section. But eight years later, are so many documentaries made? Are “Hazard” and “Ronaldo” shirts hanging in the rafters? Does the victory still taste quite as sweet?

Identity is the essential part of supporting a football team. And I don’t just mean regional identity, or sectarian identity, but the sense that this team, in some bizarre, transcendent way, represent you, and you them. That their losses are your own, and each victory your victory. Of course, you have no actual role in the outcome, at least not a direct one, but nevertheless; winning is only joyous if it feels shared. I remember, in 2019, complaining outside the Emirates Stadium after a 2-0 loss to a different Leicester side that there wasn’t a single Arsenal player whose name I’d wear on the back of a shirt. Not one of them played beautiful football, or looked like a loss would keep them up. None of them abstained from diving, or kissed the badge (though that does tend to require scoring first, which wasn’t a collective strong suit either). And in fairness, none of them are obliged to do any of that (except perhaps scoring).

I remember, in 2019, complaining that there wasn’t a single Arsenal player whose name I would wear on the back of a shirt

They’re professionals, after all, not soldiers. But I remember then saying how I didn’t care if Arsenal ever won anything again. I just wanted a team I could support. Aged well, that. We’ve won nothing these past few years (though, granted, our results have improved), but I love each and every player and coach on this team. I’d get the f*cking kit manager on the back of a shirt. Not because they’re champions, but because their MY team, whatever irrational, primal desire that represents. They have an identity with which I identify. They care. They play together. So when a manager like Ange Postecoglou insists that an identity must not break, present results be damned, I can’t help but sympathise. Even if that manager is talking about Tottenham.

However, there is a flipside to this. Arsenal have, of late, due to their defensive gameplans against fierce rivals, been accused of Dark Arts by many pundits, commentators and players alike. They say we don’t, unlike that Tottenham team we beat 1-0, play the right way. This is, in my naturally impartial opinion, utter bollocks. Away from home, our star midfielder out, and often a man down, do they expect us to do our best Invincibles impression? But still, I have to admit that this line of argument comes from a similar place as Ange’s; from the idea that beautiful football and loyalty are virtues in themselves, worth commendation equal to their efficacy.

So am I rose-tinted to assert that winning is secondary to these things, when I celebrated stuffing Spurs with vindictive glee? Perhaps a little. That Leicester team started the season guns blazing, choc full for 4-2s and 3-1s, but they didn’t win the title that way. They won with 1-0 wins that would bore most any neutral. They won by playing tight, sitting back, focusing on defence. It’s a cliche to say that defence wins championships, and not a wholly truthful one – you can’t win if you don’t score – but it touches on a reality of adaptability. Knowing when to stop, when to resign your values and play to win, even if some beauty and footballing identity is lost. And so rises the dichotomy, the fine line that so many coaches have failed to tread. There’s no joy in cheated victories, whether on the pitch or off it. There’s little more in dull, uninspired ones, to boot. But there’s just as little joy in losing, time in, time out, in defence of an identity that feels increasingly more like that of a naive idiot than of a sparkling idealist. A balance, somewhere, must be struck.

I, personally, hope Ange Postecoglu never finds it.

Кирилл Венедиктов via Wikimedia Commons