Review: The Pillowman
By Lottie Heslop

As Halloween season draws to a close, First Theatre Company’s The Pillowman is an excellently eerie experience for those, like myself, who are desperate to remain in the spooky mood. Set in a totalitarian police state, I must offer trigger warnings for police brutality, child abuse, sexual assault and murder. Though, this is anything but a tragedy. Even the ghastliest elements of the crimes committed are punctuated with razor-sharp black comedic one liners sure to tickle even the most frigid audience. Katurian’s sinister stories featuring suicide, torture and piglets, strangely enough, offer far more than simply shock-value, but beg questions about the role and personal responsibility of the writer, and the sheer dangerous power of literature to inspire.
The impeccable comic timing and characterisation of the whole cast is a major highlight of the play. Horatio Holloway perfectly embodies Karturian as both the awkward creative with his invariably skewed priorities as well as his emotional, ferocious performance as the plot unfolds and he is subjected to further brutality. Delivering extensive monologued stories, Holloway does outstandingly well in hooking your interest and maintaining it. The great contrast between his exceptionally impassioned portrayal and the innocent delivery of his brother, Michal, makes for some hilariously heart-breaking dialogue. From the beginning however, Louise Coggrave steals much of the show as the hot-headed ‘bad-cop’ of the narrative, providing a great tensity in the first half and then developing an understanding sympathy for this misunderstood character in the second. Beth Presswood as Tupolski truly shone in the second half, with her impeccable comic timing showcasing the cold callousness of her character.
The impeccable comic timing and characterisation of the whole cast is a major highlight of the play
On entering, the audience faces a set up with a table and two chairs, one seating a figure, their head covered in a brown cloth bag; thus, from the moment you enter, you are transported to the dingy prison cell in which Katurian is being held, with unnerving, immersive music already giving you a feel of the eeriness to come. Repeated use of a certain strange track as Karturian’s stories come to life provides a great motif that sets the mood of this gloriously dark yet dreadfully funny production. While the tech department certainly had such moments of greatness, the lighting sometimes did contradict the creepiness of the tales. Perhaps an intentional effect to offset the depravity of the source matter however, as an avid horror fan I will always be one to vouch for a little more creepiness, blood and gore.
The incorporation of choreographed physical movement to portray the tales is an excellent idea and the use of shadows – particularly in ‘The Tale of the Town on the River’ to exaggerate and dramatize the sizes of the characters, the little boy in comparison to the foreboding traveller – is superbly in keeping with the horrific absurdity of the piece. Yet, some areas of timing and pacing were slightly lacking, and were slightly incongruous with the narration. However, the creepy yet cute Pillowman’s personification, in costuming and movement was definitely a highlight. While much of Karturian’s work purely disturbs, the Pillowman leaves us questioning our own moral alliances. The comically superfluous and silly representation of Tupolski’s own story elicited many laughs and was intentionally hysterical in its contrast to the other movement pieces.
The incorporation of choreographed physical movement to portray the tales is an excellent idea
All of this would have been made even the more effective had the play been suitably trimmed. The length of the play, beginning at 7:30pm and ending closer to 11pm with a short interval, did mean moments of comedic genius and superb acting were slightly overshadowed by the sheer length of two-person scenes mixed with minimal set change. If cut down, the hilarity of the twists and turns in the play are sure to carry greater weight and allow this cast to shine even more.
Particularly, the electrifying comedy duo of Ariel and Tupolski in the second half, though already eliciting amazing audience reaction, would be all the more enjoyed. In any case, their faultless comedic timing and physical characterisation provides an effective uplift from the brutality and barbarity of the themes explored.
Overall, the play is a bewildering mixture of barbarity and beauty mixed with hilarity and an extremely talented cast sure to provide a perfect last dose of spectacular spookiness this Halloween season.
Image credit: First Theatre Company

