Can Starmer regain control of leadership?

By Cai Wardhaugh

The first 100 days of Sir Keir Starmer’s Labour government should have been a celebration of the majority that the party won in July, but instead his leadership has been buffeted by “Freebiegate” and political instability in No 10. Labour’s campaign offered a government-in-waiting, and despite important policy announcements, an ambiguous communications strategy in No 10 has left the public disenchanted with this new Labour government. 
 
During the election campaign, Starmer outlined five central “missions” that would define his leadership: economic growth, clean energy, tackling crime, improving the NHS and removing “barriers to opportunity”. The public seems oblivious to these. Starmer has angered voters on two fronts by cutting winter fuel payments, an untimely pre-budget announcement, and the early release of some prisoners. Policy aside, the Puritan image which he often invoked in the general election has been tarnished by “Freebiegate” and infighting. Despite some credible policy announcements made in the King’s speech, any measure of progress against those 5 missions has been lost to an unbreaking wave of media hostility exacerbated by a pitiful communications response from No 10. 
 
“Freebiegate” revealed that Starmer and other senior ministers had taken gifts of clothes, hospitality and accommodation worth thousands of pounds from Labour donors, most notably Lord Waheed Alli. Whilst this story was undoubtedly surprising and damaging for the government, it is not an extraordinary scandal for a UK government to experience. Its continued domination of the news cycle seems to have stemmed from the inadequate No 10 communications response. Rather than a New Labour style response of making headline-grabbing government policy announcements to move the news cycle on, the No 10 communications machine repeatedly stuttered in the face of media scrutiny. Starmer’s initial response was legalistic, emphasising that he had never broken any rules. This did not convince either the media or the public. He then offered to pay back some of the donations, which opened his other ministers to attacks. If he were paying back a select few donations, then would Ms Rayner? Or Ms Reeves? The lack of a coherent response from No 10 left Starmer’s government’s reputation tarnished by what should have been a relatively minor scandal.

The lack of a coherent response from No 10 left Starmer’s government’s reputation tarnished by what should have been a relatively minor scandal

Similarly, the infighting in No 10 that eventually led to the ousting of Sue Gray has further damaged the managerial image that Starmer’s election campaign projected. The McSweeney vs Gray power struggle played out in the domain of public affairs, with bitter briefings about Ms Gray given by her opponents in No 10. This was enabled by Ms Gray’s political own goal of accepting a salary marginally greater than Sir Keir’s. This highlighted the instability at the heart of government. The public nature of this dispute has further tarnished Starmer’s first 100 days in office. 
 
The focus for the government now lies in changing the narrative. It is important to remember that significant decisions have still been made: planning reforms, GB energy and the partial Israeli arms embargo. Apart from the well-received handling of the riots, Sir Keir’s leadership has been uncertain. Two opportunities arise to correct the narrative – the replacement of Gray with the more politically-minded Morgan McSweeney, who masterminded the election campaign, and the Autumn Budget. Mr McSweeney must build a positive story for the government, and deal with routine scandals competently. The Budget must also build a hopeful vision for the future of Britain, contrasting with the doom and gloom narrative that dominated the Labour Party conference. 
 
Government communication must be better. This is because communications are vital for maintaining public support and government morale – they shape the country’s conversation. Communications issues produced a downbeat Labour conference, exacerbated “Freebiegate” and speculation around instability in No 10. Taking control of communications will help rectify some of the own goals scored by Starmer’s government in its first 100 days. It is the vital remedy to regain control of the government’s narrative. 

Image: Simon Dawson via Wikimedia Commons