Shipping migrants back to Turkey is a doomed project

By Vicky Jessop

The latest update on the migrant crisis: the EU and Turkey have put their heads together and decided on behalf of the thousands of migrants currently sheltering in Greece that the best thing for them is undoubtedly, categorically to ship them right back where they have come from. Ferries stuffed with migrants started to leave for Turkey last month, heading back to a place that has given them a lukewarm reception at best – and last week we got the news that Greece has already had to stall the ferry departures in order to cope with fairly important things like actually sorting the operation out with minimal staff, in the middle of a crippling financial crisis.

Why should we be surprised that this plan is already failing? It was doomed from the start, more than doomed, it was self-defeating. Even the premise of shipping migrants back to a country in order to let the same number of migrants in at the Greco-Turkish border smacks of desperation. Rather than wasting time and manpower on something that will ultimately make no difference to the crisis currently taking place in Greece, wouldn’t it be better for the EU to work towards creating a sustainable plan that benefits not just the EU but the people currently fleeing war and destruction? These people have just lost their livelihoods and have risked their lives trying to get to a place they have traditionally seen as welcoming. In return we have closed the borders and started to see them as an inconvenience rather than as people in their own right. Any plan that involves people volunteering to be sent back to the Turkey they have risked their lives to escape hangs on a knife edge anyway, but shouldn’t the threats of suicide from the people threatened with deportation at least make us feel uneasy about what it is the EU is attempting here?

Indeed, what is being attempted here is the execution of a project that should take months of preparation in less than two weeks. Greece’s own budget and taskforce is currently being stretched to the limit by the competing demands both of the migrant crisis and of actually running a country that is not only suffering a financial meltdown but is currently one of the poorest in all of Europe. Rather than openly acknowledge this the EU gave it a deadline of two weeks to sort out cross-channel shipping and all the rigmarole that comes with it (the rigmarole in this case being staff, payments, and the establishment and operation of a massive bureaucratic and justice system to process migrant applications with) on a minimal budget. The further staff members promised by the EU to help handle this so far haven’t arrived, so Greece has effectively been left to cope with this problem by itself. No wonder it had to halt those ferry departures.

But surely the real reason that this project should be doomed is the fact that there is no long-term solution for the migrants once they actually arrive back in Turkey. The government has arranged for tents to be erected on the docks to accommodate the flow of people being shipped back, but once they arrive, where are they going to stay in the long-term? Surely not in the migrant camps where hundreds of thousands of people are living in squalor, metres from the border to Europe? One thing is for certain: these people will not go back to the countries they fled from. Nobody knows how long the influx of refugees is going to last, but by this point there needs to be more of a long-term plan to process and deal with these people. This desperate, frantic struggle to kick them out, to pretend that the problem is going to go away when it clearly is not, is not going to work. We owe it to everybody to find a sustainable plan.

Photograph: Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Daniel Barker, via Wikimedia Commons