Short skirts, sex and the schoolgirl
By Anna Webster
“Temptation, frustration / So bad it makes him cry / Wet bus stop, she’s waiting / His car is warm and dry / Don’t stand, don’t stand so / Don’t stand so close to me…”
Ring any bells? The Police’s hit single “Don’t Stand So Close to Me” about a student-teacher affair, stems back to Sting’s days as a secondary school teacher and the oh-so-tempting underage schoolgirls he found so hard to resist. “I wanted to write a song about sexuality in the classroom,” he explained. “I’d done teaching practice at secondary schools and been through the business of having 15-year-old girls fancying me – and me really fancying them! How I kept my hands off them I don’t know…”
And Sting isn’t the only one. The deputy principal of a school in New Zealand has recently told girls to lengthen their skirts so as not to “distract” male staff and pupils. In July 2015, the head teacher of Trentham High School in Stoke-on-Trent announced he was banning skirts altogether because “it’s not pleasant for male members of staff and students, the girls have to walk up stairs and sit down and it’s a complete distraction.” Later in the year it was reported that the same school sent home 10 girls whose trousers were deemed too tight because they would prove a “distraction” to male teachers. And last year a student in the US was sent home from school for wearing a shirt that revealed her collarbones.
Skirts too “short”, trousers too “tight”, shirts too “low”, one wonders what is so scandalous about the lower inch of a girl’s thigh, or the bones below her neck? And why aren’t boys subjected to just as many rules about their uniform? Whilst the head teacher at Tring School, Sue Collings, may be right that “students looking smart and professional is an important element of being a successful school”, in a school’s attempt to define smartness there are always far more rules concerning a girl’s uniform than a boy’s. The truth is that girl’s bodies are policed far more than boy’s bodies because they are sexualised far more than boy’s bodies, to the extent that girls are being denied access to the classroom and their right to learn.
However, whilst some girls might genuinely struggle to find a skirt that both fits their waist and meets the length requirement, many of us, it cannot be denied, choose to roll-up our school skirts. Why? To follow the fashion; to be accepted. Yet no matter how hard schools try to implement a knee-length skirt, girls will always find the rules of society more persuasive than the rules of school. If society and the media tell girls that skirts should be short, then the weight of this societal pressure will far outweigh the threat of a lunch-time detention.
Schools may be partly justified in arguing that they are preparing their pupils for the world of work; yet by pulling girls out of classes and publicly shaming them, I agree with feminist Laura Bates that they are only preparing girls for a “sexist and unfair working world in which women are constantly judged and berated on their appearance.” Furthermore, by treating girls from such a young age as though they are sexual objects, there is a high risk that girls will grow up to believe it, and this could lead them into careers I am sure their school would not be so keen to have essentially prepared them for.
But it is not just schools that teach girls they are sexual objects; the media takes it to another level. According to the media, schoolgirls are sexy. One only needs to watch Britney Spears’ video “Hit Me Baby One More Time” – as she dances in her mini-skirt, her unbuttoned, cropped school shirt and her pink-ribboned pigtails – to understand that school girls are not just sexy in the eyes of a sexually frustrated male adolescent or school teacher, but in worldwide, mainstream, popular culture. The St Trinian’s films are another example. And as much as we can shake our heads in disapproval, we can’t deny that it is everywhere: from the worldwide cinema screens to the local school-disco themed club nights. So how much can girls really be blamed for choosing to wear their skirt that bit higher than the school regulation, when the whole of society unconsciously accepts that it should be even shorter?
As the media plays into the idea of a school-uniform, it is playing into the image of childhood. This idea of the ‘sexy schoolgirl’ seems to come from a highly disturbing lust for young, inexperienced, virginal girls, which is exploited everywhere, by the media and celebrities alike. In February last year, Selena Gomez did a topless photoshoot for V magazine which sparked a great amount of controversy as fans felt she was made to look considerably younger. She poses with large, red, childish hoops dangling from her ears; a mini-mouse bow in her hair; large, startled doe-like eyes and a dumb-founded expression on her face. Unsurprisingly, the comment “She looks like an absolute 12-year-old” was a frequently occurring reaction. Whilst Sting jokes lightly about fancying 15-year-old girls, in reality he is confessing to a much darker fancy in which school-girls are blameless victims. He may choose to shrug-off any guilt in being sexually attracted to underage girls, but ultimately it is unacceptable and the fact that male staff are incapable of teaching a lesson because a girl’s trousers are apparently “too tight” is frankly pathetic.
I still remember my own headmistress saying to the girls “Let’s not excite the boys” and at the time it felt justified. But we were being made to feel guilty for distracting the boys, as though it was all our fault. Perhaps some girls endorse the image of ‘sexy schoolgirl’ to an extent, but can any of us claim to be entirely free from the pressures forced upon us by society?
At the end of the day it all goes back to this accusation throughout history that women use their ‘female allurements’ to deliberately tempt men away from the pursuit of reason. We are blamed for their obsessive sexual passions, and, thanks to Eve, the ultimate seductress and the symbolic Mother to all women, we are blamed for the entire supposed Fall of Man!
This issue of school uniform cannot be resolved by simply enforcing stricter regulations. Girls cannot be held fully responsible because they are blameless victims in this perverted case. Instead, the greater issue is that society sexualises schoolgirls, who are then punished when men find them sexy. This deep-rooted problem that can be traced backwards in history for centuries. Instead of blaming and punishing women, schools and authorities should at least try to address tyhiif they insist on having their knee-length skirts and their high-collar shirts.
Photographs: elmimmo via Flickr
