The end of trade unionism?
By Vicky Jessop
It seems like a week never goes by but there’s a strike on national television for us all to panic over: the junior doctors striking over pay, the Underground staff closing the Tube and stranding thousands of panicked tourists in Piccadilly with no idea of how to make it to the other side of London, or even the teachers deciding that enough was enough and making the days of school children up and down the country by closing the schools. The nearly constant news coverage of this simply, for me, drives home the fact that trade unions are on the television far too often – and this, apparently, is something that the new parliament is aiming to address.
First of all, it really has to be said that unions are useful – indeed, necessary – in any properly democratic society which wants to give its workforce a fair say in how their jobs are regulated. Trade unions have only really come about in the last hundred years or so, born out of a society which thrived on the oppression of its workforce, and the fact that we have them at all is a sign of how much more equal our society is today, a century after the Victorians have gone. Trade unions were created to protect the workforce, to offer them a chance at equal pay and to guard their interests when the government wouldn’t. That’s all good and that’s something we should definitely stand behind. After all, who doesn’t want job security and somebody to have their back like that? If you don’t like how much you’re getting paid, you strike, and hopefully the employers will cave. Sometimes it’s the most effective – and only – way of making yourself heard.
It is also true that unions can be very influential in the way in which they wield their power. They represent the combined workforce of over half the country, after all, and that can make any employer nervous. Many a politics student or over-fifty year old will often fire up on that most infamous of subjects: Thatcher and seventies-era Britain. It has been a long time since trade unions crippled the country. People either love or hate Thatcher as they love or hate Marmite, but she did get the country back on its feet – though it really isn’t something that we should forget. That the unions did this should absolutely serve as a warning about the damage that these massive bodies can inflict, especially on the economy, but the fact remains that, after Thatcher, the unions were reformed and their power limited.
So why are the government trying to limit this power even more? This new bill which parliament is proposing to move would again drastically curb the already restricted powers that these unions wield. The proposed bill would cut the ability of these unions to raise funding and make their presence felt in the workplace, as well as make it harder for workers to strike and protest against their employers in the first place. Surely, bearing in mind the need for a democratic society that takes everybody’s needs seriously, this is dangerous? The only power they do have that actually makes an impact on normal society is the power to strike; if this is taken away from them then they basically become figureheads for the workers and not much more. The worst thing is that Cameron and his government are pushing it through despite staunch opposition from both the Welsh and Scottish Assembly governments.
Bearing in mind, therefore, that trade unions are necessary for the fair representation of the workforce in a democratic society, shouldn’t the fact that they are being beaten and shaped into nothing more dangerous than the government’s lapdog be cause for concern? Perhaps, before this bill goes through, Cameron should take a look at the opposition coming in from all corners and reconsider his position.
Photograph: Wikipedia via Creative Commons
