Sex On Screen
By Grace Jessop
Sex on the screen – I wonder what your first experience of it was? My own was a premature viewing of Love Actually aged ten at a friend’s house – her older sister was watching it with her friends and we clandestinely snuck in the room. Being exposed to a universe of Martin Freeman pretending to have sex with “the lady from Gavin and Stacey”, Hugh Grant as Sexy PM™, and Colin-God-of-Sex living it up in the US with all those awfully slaggy Americans, curated by our much-beloved Richard Curtis was perhaps a fitting entry into the world of sex in cinema: a world filled with sometimes funny and tender scenes, served with shades of sexual harassment masked as amusing kerfuffle’s from terribly-nice British chaps, with a side of fatphobia and general jolly creepiness mixed in. Perhaps I’m being unfair, and Curtis’ 2003 film isn’t that bad at showing sex, due to its nature as a ‘product of its time’ it is in fact vaguely progressive on several counts.
50 Shades of Grey is a primary guilty party, portraying a misinformed version of fetish-sex
Despite some faults, Love Actually is perching in a middling space, leaning towards the ok, on the spectrum of problematic sex scenes in film. More uncomfortable issues live elsewhere: the softcore erotica which has bled its way into the mainstream. 50 Shades of Grey is a primary guilty party, portraying a misinformed version of fetish-sex. It feels difficult to criticise this to a certain extent; I don’t intend to shame or blame cinema that shows ‘unvanilla’ sex in any way, nor the people who enjoy having kinky sex. But the way in which this kind of sex is portrayed in this film is not only a poor take on BDSM according to many members of the community, but in addition removes much of the human connection and communication involved in the practice – not like the controlling and at times non-consensual behaviour seen in 50 Shades. Emily Sarah, a fetish model further points out in an interview with the Guardian that in real BDSM sex there is plenty more imperfection, ‘smudged makeup and spit and sweat’.
If mainstream cinema can’t portray kinky sex vaguely right, then mixed messages that seep through the cracks of pop culture could result in damaging consequences for young people learning about what they think is hot in sex and how they conduct themselves in achieving that in their relationships. Pushing, grabbing, hitting, slapping – there are many things that in a consenting adult relationship are perfectly permissible. But in other contexts, sexual or not, these things can quickly and easily constitute abuse.
Normal People – its focus on consent, trust and importance of mutual respect was somewhat ground-breaking
Arguably, the joke of a film 365 Days which Variety surmises as ‘a vacuous idiot is kidnapped by a hot, rich mafioso and given 365 days to fall in love with this objectionable ludicrous softcore fantasy’, which elegantly pardons kidnapping, gives a pat on the back to rape culture and is awash with misogyny aplenty, was facilitated by the already questionable 50 Shades. The fact the film went viral on TikTok with (predominantly) teenage girls claiming it to be a foundation of super sexy content speaks for itself – if young people are exposed to problematic sex on mainstream channels, therefore purifying it somehow, they’re going to digest it as more acceptable, and in turn accept it.
Of course it’s not all bad, and there are many demonstrations of funny and fumbled consensual sex in cinema in accurate portrayals, which people adore and rave about – we want to see familiarity in film, albeit a slightly prettier version of familiarity, including in its sex scenes. Although of course it’s not strictly cinema, there’s a reason you’ll find Google drenched in opinion pieces on the portrayal of sex in Normal People – its focus on consent, trust and importance of mutual respect was somewhat ground-breaking.
Despite the fact sex has been used as a device in film for decades (not just to show beautiful young people tentatively having their first sexual experiences with one another) must we accept that the only alternative to spot-on portrayals are morally questionable situations? I hope not, and I hope that we quash the narrative that is traversing through screenplays that women only find pleasure in pain.
Image by Erik Lucatero on Unsplash
