No domestic abuse victim should be ignored
By Daisy Robinson
On 2nd November, Johnny Depp lost his libel case against The Sun in London’s High Court over claims he beat Amber Heard, fuelling the fire created when he was found guilty of 12 out of 14 reported incidents of assault reported by Heard. The results of this trial have gathered a lot of media attention over the last few weeks due to debate over who the real victim of this case is.
Depp has vehemently denied Heard’s allegations since she first made them in 2016, and claimed he was the victim, declaring to a judge that Heard committed “innumerable acts of domestic violence”. Depp’s solicitor backed up this claim, finding it “bewildering” that an array of evidence presented was disregarded.
However, the Centre for Women’s Justice has hailed the court’s decisions as important ones that prove that fame and financial resources cannot silence female survivors of domestic violence. Although the general public do not have access to the full array of evidence provided in court and therefore cannot make a fully informed judgement on which side of this case is correct, its high profile has sparked conversations in how our society view male victims of domestic abuse.
Perceptions of men as strong and silent are inherently dangerous
In 2018, 576,000 men were victims of partner abuse; nearly half of these victims failed to tell anyone. Men are three times less likely to tell someone than women, feeling out of fear that they are less likely to be believed, or it will damage their masculinity. We may be moving forward as a society in dismantling toxic masculinity, but perceptions of men as strong and silent are inherently dangerous.
Men will stay in an abusive relationship for three years on average before reaching out, often because they doubt their validity as a victim. Putting up with abuse for this long understandably does not make the problem disappear, and can therefore lead to more drastic consequences, such as suicide.
The charity Men Standing Up was specifically created to deal with another of these severe outcomes: homelessness. Without their support, an anonymous survivor reported states that “it was killing me from the inside… If it wasn’t for Men Standing Up, I wouldn’t have known what to do – I could’ve been dead.”
For male, female and non-binary victims of abuse, it is never their fault, and what they undergo can be bewildering and traumatic. Anyone with an ounce of compassion should sympathise with a victim of abuse of any gender. However, stereotypes of men and women have been detrimental to all perceptions of abuse, and society is more likely to understand female victims than men. Assuming that men’s strength means they can take physical abuse both trivialises the pain they undergo, and equally distorts what feminists mean when they talk about empowered women.
We must listen to both sides and resist the urge to make assumptions based on gender
These embedded gender norms are ones some people unconsciously retain, but are being worked against by many domestic abuse charities. However, the majority of this hard work has been carried out by female-centred charities or under the cross-government strategy aimed at ending violence against women. It was not until 2019 that the Home Office published a statement promising millions of pounds to support groups of male victims of all sexualities and to improve awareness campaigns.
This is a great start, but work still needs to be done in firmly establishing this support system for male victims, for example in providing more refuge spaces for men. Equally, support should be focused on helping men understand and recognise the seriousness of abuse. This work needs to be made structurally by the Government, but we also have a part to play.
In cases like Depp and Heard’s, we must listen to both sides of the argument and resist the urge to make assumptions based on either party’s gender. Domestic abuse should always be taken seriously and we must offer support to survivors through listening and believing them. Survivors of domestic abuse do not deserve to suffer in silence, and there are a variety of services, including the National Domestic Abuse helpline, to support whoever may need them.
Image: Fan D via Flickr
