Revisiting ‘Fat Is A Feminist Issue’
By Millie Fender
Watching Durham’s fantastic performance in the first round of ‘University Challenge’ in August, there was only one question they faced which I knew the answer to.
‘Which British psychoanalyst wrote the 1978 work ‘Fat Is A Feminist Issue’, a critique of the diet industry and social attitudes towards women’s weight?’
The answer is, as Paxman brusquely corrected our team, Susie Orbach.
When Orbach’s brand of feminism became marketable, it ended up feeding into the capitalist system it once sought to undermine.
I read Fat Is A Feminist Issue five years ago, plagued by body issues so commonplace and obvious they’re hardly worth noting here. The book taught me a lot- it helped me to realise that I was the product of a society which seeks to plant seeds of insecurity in women’s minds, and make them question their own bodies before they’ve even been taught the biological functions they serve. It’s one of those rare books you read as a philosophy student which both startles and compels you by speaking a truth which you’ve always been aware of but never really articulated or grasped before. Reaching its 40th anniversary recently, Orbach remarked in an article for The Guardian: ‘I thought my book would change the world. How did things get worse?’
In a way, Orbach is wrong. She has undoubtedly changed the world; premising a brand of feminism which, 35 years later, has gone mainstream and dominated many modern schools of thought and Instagram feeds. But therein lies the problem- the anti-diet, anti-capitalist polemic has fed into the undeniably marketable and current trend of ‘body positivity’; a bold movement in which women reclaim their bodies, their ‘flaws’, and proclaim them beautiful. The noble sentiment is oft-subverted, with brands heralding girls with the same proportions as those who dominate modern beauty standards (read: the Kardashians) as inspiring, body-positive influencers.
it helped me to realise that I was the product of a society which seeks to plant seeds of insecurity in women’s minds
The goalposts may have moved; perhaps now we aren’t conditioned with a complete aversion to anything ‘fat’, but our fat must be in the right places- lining our upper thighs and bums, padding our breasts, but never on our stomachs, waists or arms. This isn’t a victory for Orbach (or for the sentiment of body positivity), but simply more damaging rhetoric disguising itself in a marketable feminist cause. When Orbach’s brand of feminism became marketable, it ended up feeding into the capitalist system it once sought to undermine.
Whilst Orbach was ahead of the body-positivity curve, she cannot be straightforwardly married with many of the movement’s ideals. Her emphasis is not on finding one’s own unique brand of beauty, or reforming the standards which dominate our lives, it’s to dispense of this idea altogether and renounce involvement in arbitrary beauty standards. Our bodies have straightforwardly biological functions. Why must the basic act of nourishing ourselves, the most natural of human instincts, be subverted to anything other than this?
Orbach remarked in an article for The Guardian: ‘I thought my book would change the world. How did things get worse?’
The diet industry, Orbach argues, has become yet more rapacious and ruthless in choosing its prey- who to imbue next with that ache of inadequacy. Targets are younger, further enabled by parents who have also succumbed to the narrative.
So, is fat just a feminist issue any more? The sole focus of the 1978 book is women- for the obvious reason that it is women who are held to increasingly absurd expectations. However, the emergence of ‘bigorexia’ or muscle dysmorphia, and the increase in other eating disorders in men, in line with growth in numbers in women, would suggest that the issue now spans all genders. In her Guardian article, Orbach writes ‘it is sometimes possible to feel that when we are talking of bodies we aren’t engaging in serious economic and social issues, but we are.’ Making people hate themselves is a multi-billion dollar industry, and the more subtle business striving to like yourself again – the sort of liking yourself which comes with unspoken limits and conditions- is even more powerful. Why would businesses not expand and target the uncharted market of men’s self-esteem?
is fat just a feminist issue any more?
Whilst I’ve deemed the text a polemic, it’s important to note that Orbach’s book functions as a self-help text. In line with her primarily biological conception of the human body and nourishment, her own approach focuses on listening to the body and giving your body what it wants when it wants. Maybe Durham didn’t get five points for this question on University Challenge, but its students could gain a lot more than this by reading the text themselves.
Photograph: Susie Orbach via LSE Library on Flickr Creative Commons
